Better Eagles Hit? Brown on Reggie Bush / Dawkins on Crumpler

Dawkins on Crumpler because it's was during an extremely important game and set the tone to go to the SB.

GOOD POINT! LOVE DAWKINS!

How bout they both are nasty hits!

nah brown in my opinion ended all the reggie bush hype he hasnt been the same since

whatever man Reggie coming back this year

Drew hung him out to dry, I was at the dome that game the place went silent....

gotta go with Brown

Remember when Stewart Bradley picked off Brees, well Brown caused it watch his hit on Henderson.

they are nasty just cant pick one

I like the dawkins hit better. Remember the one Redskins/Eagles game couple years back when dawkins suplexed the dude right at the sidelines? That was my favorite probably.

brown on bush was a better hit...but the hit on crumpler told a story....it kinda showed how the eagles hit the whole NFC in the mouth that year and nothing could stop them to the superbowl

Well said.

Brown on Reggie Bush

Brown on Bush was sinister!!!!!!

Sheldon Browns hit was immortalized on the cover of SI. But how could anyone forget "puppykiller" Vick getting FREIGHTTRAINED by Hollis Thomas in '04?
http://youtube.com/watch?v=Hnd-4LHebuc

we let thomas go too soon! another nice hit!

that was the same game as the dawkins hit

They kicked ass that year

Brown on bush. He made him crawl LOL

Brown - you could feel that hit. You could tell it put the fear of Eagles into the Sints.

buddy ryan would have loved them both,flipe a coin !

brown shutup all the saints with that hit

dawk told the nfl hes tha best

they're both 10/10 hits

both hits were tremendous but i give it to dawks for difficultly alot harder to put that kind of pop on Crumpler than it is Bush.

Anybody remember the hit Dawk put on Toomer. He got fined on the hit. I just love seeing the Eagles deliver big hits.

I remember both hits and I remember when Brown hit Bush I jumped and started yelling and ya hear my parents sayin OH THATS GOTTA HURT SO I GO WITH BROWN ON BUSH

That why its #1 on my list

i go 2 go with brown mostly because when he smashed bush he dropped the ball and crumpler held onto the ball but they are both awesome hits

Both are under different circumstances. One was a hard hit in a championship game that we ended up winning, while the other was a hard hit in a playoff game which we ended up losing.

If you just took the two hits side by side and did not factor in the effect they had on the game then I would say that Brown's hit looked like it had more hate and more force put into it. While B-dawks was still a hard hit, browns was harder.

That being said, a hit isn't jack unless it effects the outcome of the game in some manor. Sure bush was shaken up but he came right back. After Dawkins rocked Crumplers world he was not as effective in that championship game.

So after much consideration I would have to say that Weapon-X's hit on Crumpler was the better hit!

Good point it made my top 10
http://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/Top_10_NFL_Hits/285814

both good hits..but i still say that was a fumble on the reggie bush hit....

They were both really really great hit. Brown's was better. I think it was a fumble to. That was a great game tho. Iove to see the Eagles D coming up with some great hits. GO EAGLES

Is it true that Dawkins took out michael irving? I heard about it but never seen it.

Actually I just looked it up and it was Hauck and Bobby Taylor that took him out.

the dawk hit on crumpler was more impressive due to the fact of crumps weight, end of story
dawk is god.
T

Bush got hammered

Crumper hit was more impressive due to the fact that Alge outweighed Dawkins by like 50 pounds.