For those of you who still think that Dallas should have drafted Mendenhall...

Here is an excerpt from an article written by Mickey Spagnola. He breaks this down quite well. "Now then, if you'll just put those veins back in your neck and think a minute, the Cowboys did add speed to this offense - to this team - if you are willing to think a little outside the box. Think Felix Jones. And do not think traditional running back. Think Reggie Bush knockoff. Think lining up in the backfield. Think lining up in the slot. Think lining up wide. Think end arounds. Think reverses. Think defenses having to do whatever is necessary to keep him from getting in the open field. Felix Jones will stretch the field. Felix Jones will threaten defenses. Felix Jones will scare the dickens out of coverage units. As Jerry Jones was quick to point, "This is the most speed we've had since . . . well, since Joey Galloway." And he's talking young speed. Which means, the solution to the second problem many had with this Cowboys draft is the answer to the first complaint. Mendenhall is no Felix Jones. He might turn out to be a franchise running back for Pittsburgh, but he would be no complement to Marion Barber, the guy so many think is the Cowboys' franchise running back. (Timeout: I remember this e-mailer warning about drafting a running back. He warned everyone will fall in love with the guy, and suddenly those who wanted Barber to overtake Julius Jones would immediately begin crying for the new guy, Felix Jones as it turns out, to overtake Barber. He wrote, you watch and see.) Mendenhall and Barber would be salt and salt. Gotta have you some pepper. Step aside, let Felix season this dish. "I could see how he could bring a lot of wow," Jerry Jones said of his pre-draft thoughts. "He would bring a different dimension." Having handed Jerry Jones a little secret truth serum, he said going into the draft he had Felix Jones on his mind, and that if he could have even given up picks to assure drafting him before the process begun, he would have done that. That's how much the Cowboys wanted to add this kind of speed to their offense. "I could see how he fit in," Jerry Jones said. The Cowboys also worried how Mendenhall would handle the time-share approach to the position. There were no concerns with Felix Jones. That's what he did in college. Plus, Felix Jones is a worker, and as you can see, that's become big on the Cowboys' draft criteria. And I hear there is this argument the Cowboys didn't draft their board, that they took the lower-rated back. I'm told, if they graded players on a scale from 1 to 100 (and they don't, my example), if Mendenhall was a 93, then Felix Jones was a 92. Come on, what are we doing here, splitting hairs? You take what you need, and this team needed speed, and the Cowboys knew darn well they weren't going to get it at wide receiver. There was no first-round speed there. And while Mendenhall is no turtle, he's one of those one-cut runners. Felix Jones has the necessary wiggle to make more than one guy miss. Now I would have protested Felix Jones had he cost the Cowboys a starting-quality corner. He didn't. I would have protested Felix Jones had the Cowboys not paired him in this draft with another running back. They did, the Cowboys also selecting Choice, giving them three running backs they seemed convinced will make their game-day 45-man roster. So what's the beef, unless of course, you've just got to beef. And if that's the case, and makes you happy, please, by all means, go beef. But if you do, you just might be missing the boat" Still think Mendenhall was the better choice for the Cowboys? I don't.

43 Comments On: "For those of you who still think that Dallas should have drafted Mendenhall..."

 
huh, interesting, nice read!!!

thank you. I am shocked at how many folks around here are laughing at Dallas for passing on Mendenhall. Like Felix is some scrub from a junior college or something.

i had no idea, so good for you for bloggin it!! it was a good read!!!

Yea cowboy. Felix is no scrub. What should be good is Barber lining up at fullback and Felix at RB... That would make defenses scratch there head. They would not know whether to stack up in the middle or what. Because Felix will run over a CB whenever he gets the chance... Should be a great year for the boys.

I like them in a split back. Halfbacks don't often transition well to fullback. That extra yard matters to them. Either one in motion from the backfield is a bonus for us. I will have to be sold on his blitz pickup, though, before I would even consider that. We can't have folks runnig around our backfield willy nilly.

unless it is Tony Romo.

gonna be a good one all around yeah i'm still high on the pick from yesterday ha

It does look promising, doesn't it? Especially if this Scandrick fellow can tackle and shed a blocker.

yeah it does lol and we got Mendenhall lol nice write up though

solid article

He is a better fit for your team than ours. Of course, we'd be happier if he wasn't on our schedule this season. By the way, when you use the term barnburner, are you talking about a high scoring down to the last possesion game?

LOL!!!! we'd be happier if he wasn't on our schedule this season
hehe!!! will be a fun rivalry game!!!


I ain't complaining, that's for sure. Was happy with the pick from the start. Yeah, barnburner is a real closely contested sporting event.

I wasn't just happy, I LOVED it. He was on top of my wish list for this draft. I can't wait to see what Jason Garret does with his versatility.

I'm not settled on Jones, but you're right: he is a better fit/complement in the offense and he'll allow the Boys to do more things.

If Jones is what we think he is, he will make his presence known early and often. That versatility should also help to cover for the potential lack of receiving depth. I am not sure we have as big a problem as a lot of people are saying, though. Sam Hurd is a real workhorse and a fantastic blocker, Austin did a good job stretching the field when he was out there. What concerns me is that he may have been able to do that precisely because he was rarely out there.

Jones has the speed and agility to eat both LB's and DB's lunch. They are going to have to account for him on every play that he is in there. That will definitely help open up the offense with the receivers we already have. Of course, he still has to prove that he can do it in the NFL, but I think he can.

I know he has the physical ability, the question is can he adapt mentally to being satisfied with the four yard runs. I saw a great interview with T.D. where he talked about the difference between the pros and college games. He says the biggest difference is that mentally the pro game wears you down because you can't outrun everyone, and everyone knows angles. He says that it is hard to learn to be satisfied with a couple of yards and a lot of college superstars give up.

There's no such thing as a 'franchise running back.' The minute you start building your team around that kind of disjointed thinking, the minute you become the Minnesota Vikings. This is a quarterback-driven league.



Tell that to L.T.
Quarterback driven is true but just look at the lack of postseason success for teams that can't run the ball. Besides, who is building around a runningback? If your point is to get your quarterback first then, ok, but what are you supposed to do if you try and miss? That is what happened to Minnesota. They took a great runningback because there was not a great quarterback available. Can you honestly tell me that you think drafting Peterson was a mistake? Minnesota is well on their way to building a great team and you just migjht see them go all the way with just a game manager in the near future.

Minnesota is also building a hell of a defense. Those teams that passed on Peterson are going to be kicking themselves in the butt for a long time to come.

I try not to think. Ever.

Well, I don't know about all of them, especially if Detroit loses Roy Williams but they are building that team from the inside out. It began with Hutch a couple of years back and steadily improved each year since. If they ever do land a quality quarterback, they are a superbowl contender day one. Heck, without one they are a darkhorse.

LT is as soft as they come. He could have and should have played in that game in New England. He chose to sit on the sidelines and watch his QB--who had an equally if not more severe injury--play while he played the victim role.

Minnesota isn't winning anything until they get a real QB. I don't care if they have the Juice, that team will go as far as Jackson will take them--which will be nowhere.

With Jackson, they were one game within getting into the playoffs and there was a lot of buzz about them being the one team that nobody wanted to play. They have improved that team in the draft. If Jackson improves any at all, they have a shot now with Bernard Berrian and Jared Allen being added to that team.

I like the way you think.

How would you define nowhere? They missed the playoffs this season because of tiebreakers. Add Jared Allen, Benard Berrian, and a weaker conference schedule accross the board and you will probably see them make a very serious run at the playoffs. If they do make the playoffs, it will take a good team to beat them. This is not a team the loses to "hot" teams. They bring it every week.

3300 yards on the ground and 43 touchdowns in two seasons says he has what it takes to be considered not just a franchise back but THE franchise back.

To state the obvious, Mickey Spagnola's paychecks are signed by Jerry Jones. What did you expect him to say? Most indedepent observers say Mendenhall is the better player and better pick.

How did you get your time to say four hours from now?

We'll find out , won't we? The experts have been wrong way more than once. Cowboy fans and the team are more than satisfied with Felix Jones and I think that will carry on over into the season.

Did you read this? Even if you though that Mendenhall was a better runningback, he is not a return man, he is not a change of pace, and there are some work ethic questions about Mendenhall. Would you say that Mendenhall is enough better that we don't need to worry about our field position game that was not very good last year? Was he enough better that we can say goodbye to Barber because he won't sign if we have a back that does what he does and is faster. I ddn't say that Jones was better I said he is better pick for the Cowboys. Mickey's paychecks aside, if you follow his coloumn he is not afraid to say that the organization is making or has made a mistake. This just wasn't one of them.

Thank you.

There are some false premises that Cowboy fans are using to justify Jones over Mendenhall:

* Mendenhall's work ethic: By all accounts (except Internet rumors), Mendenhall is a humble, hard-working team player. He has no off-field issues, no illegitimate children, no drug problem, no hanging with the wrong crowd, no bad academics, no bad reputation. You can smear Mendenhall's character all that you want but it is without basis. On the basis of on-field work ethic: The two Arkansas backs are not known for their strength or their weightroom workouts. Mendenhall is twice as strong as Jones, was faster in numerous drills at the combine, and has a much better weight distribution than Jones. Jones height compared to his weight is like a receiver. He is going to get popped into the second row when he is running east and west. Also notice that Jones gets winded after his long winding runs. He's simply not the athlete that Mendenhall is. It's hard to find an area where Jones is the better athlete, especially for a grueling role as an NFL RB.

* Jones is more versatile: This one cracks me up. Hate to break it to everyone but a situational back is not more versatile than an every-down back, especially a situational back who is slower, skinnier, and weaker than the every-down back. This should be patently obvious to EVERYONE. And Jones will never be an every-down back.


You know what, I will grant you every argument you have listed here. I do not believe you are correct and I have seen Mendenhall play in person, but I will grant you every one of your arguments. Now address the fact that Mendenhall does not bring us a kick or punt returner, (and you can't argue that we needed help there) Why wasn't he the starting back two years ago? Why not last year? Do you know the guys who started over him? Where are they now? Can you argue that Jones is going to work out personality wise with sharing time? And what other options does Mendenhall bring with him? Jones brings a change of pace, a return game boost, and he fits perfectly with the all star personel that we already have. He played against the toughest competition in the college unlike Mendenhall. Come on, for the Cowboys he was the better pick.

* Mendenhall could play kick/punt return but you don't usually put your every-down back in that role. He is already a workhorse on the offense. If he were in that role, I am sure he would do well. Felix has had success in that role, but I think it's also risky to have him return Cowboy kickoffs. His upright, tippy-toe style may have been successful in college, but I think he is going to get popped in the pros, where the players are much faster.
* It seems odd to need to answer why a true freshman/sophomore backed up a two-time team MVP on an NCAA football team, but I've seen that argument a lot. The player ahead of him beat out a 3rd-round RB draft pick for a roster spot on the Saints, and performed admirably in his rookie NFL season. Seriously, how can you guys point to Pierre Thomas and say it's some kind insult to back him up when Mendenhall is 2.5 years younger? What do you know about Pierre Thomas? Also, a lot of scouts think Mendenhall's low mileage is not a weakness but a strength. He's never missed a game due to injury, is in excellent physical condition, and seems to be just getting better. What's not to like about that?
* The argument that Mendenhall is bad chemistry and a whiner lacks substance. Just like the speed argument can be turned upside down, just like the versatility argument can be turned upside down, just like the work ethic argument can be turned upside down, so can this argument. There's no basis in truth to it. It's bad spin to justify JJ's decision. The DMN reporter said that Mendenhall never complained about backing up Thomas.
* Mendenhall is a football player, period. He could play numerous positions and numerous roles on the field and excel at any number of them. He's not limited by size, speed, strength, or fear. Felix is more of an open field 'waterbug' and less of a contact person. There's more to football than change-of-pace plays and punt/kickoff returns. While Felix may have his specialities, he's limited by comparison to Mendenhall.
* Illinois had a tougher opponent rating than Arkansas last season.
http://www.kiva.net/~jsagarin/sports/cfsend.htm

I'm still satisfied with the drafting of Jones. You can spout crap for hours and it's not going to change anything. The Cowboys passed on Mendenhall for a reason. I guess we will find out the reason soon enough.

Oh, and we have some guy named Marion Barber to handle the tough stuff. Felix Jones is just going to be the change of pace running back. I guess strength doesn't mean much if you can't catch the guy.

Mendenhall does not have a history of being a return man. He did not play that role as a back up to Thomas and he would not play that on Marion Barber's team. Therefore he does not bring that role to the team he is going to play for. The reason that you have to answer for a true freshman and sophomore wasn't starting is because even here in Illinois we'd never heard of Mendenhall until this last season. Speed is a wash, period. 4.45 and 4.47 is a wash not an advantage. Versatility favors Jones since he can and does return kicks. You keep leaving Marion Barber out of the equation and you can't do that. He is a probowl player that we groomed and the organization loves, the fans love and the other players love. You don't just arbitrarily bench that guy and you don't draft a first round runningback to sit the bench...normally. Now if you have a guy that is just barely behind your "starter" on your draft board and he is used to returning kicks and splitting time why would you take the other guy? No one, no one is saying that Mendenhall is a waste or a bad player and in fact I am willing to concede that he should have been above Jones on the draft board. If they were far apart on the board you would be correct. They were not. They were numbers three and four on the draft board not three and seven.

By the way, you do realize that on the link you provided Ilinois is below Arkansas, right?

You also seem to forget that we got Tashard Choice to get the tough yardage also. He is also a good blitz blocker and receiver. Yes, there is more to football than punt/kickoff returns, but a good return man can ignite a team pretty quick with a spectacular return and something tells me we are going to have a few of those this year, Pacman or not.

The reason Jones gets breathing heavy after he gets past the secondary, is because if he does in fact get past the secondary he is not getting cought by anybody! Jones does everything with 100% effort. I have been watching Jones since he came to Arkansas, and he is very fast, and has very good hands, on top of that he was running in the SEC. Not the Big 10. Get real. 6'0 200 is not a WR. He was less than 50 yards from having 3000 yards rushing in 3 years, on top of that he had 23 TD's.

Mendenhall has had one good year. Not 2 not 3 ONE! But hey he was only 500 yards off of 3000. He was also the number 1 back in there system. But if he was on Arkansas he would have been the number 3 back. Mendenhall is good, and I like the way he runs, but Felix is going to fill in his position on the team a lot better than Mendenhall.

caught*

Granted, Felix will be filling in as a slot guy a lot I think...

Your comment:



Featured Stories Today
YouTube's greatest NBA mixes??
The following videos are actual YouTube mixes of real life NBA "stars." Keep in mind, someone...
 
Catching Up from Albuquerque
First I want to thank everybody for their get well wishes -- I feel way better right now than I...
Name Every Winner of the WWE/WWF Royal Rumble
There have been 21 total Royal Rumbles in the history of the World Wrestling Federation or WWE as...
Female Reporter Gets Hit With Baseball
Dawn Timmeney, a reporter for NBC10 in Philly, gets hit with a baseball while conducting an...
 
My New Contest
Im sorry its been a while. I know everyone wants to know whats goin on with me. We got into Kansas...