Top 40 NFL Running Backs Going Into 2008

first u cant put a rookie on the list if theyve never played in the nfl second
westbrook needs to be above portis and marion barber

menhall, mcfadden and stewart haven't played a down yet. can't put them on the list as top anything.

Brian Westbrook has more total yards that any other RB on the list, and this guy has him ranked #7? What? Really? You gotta be kidding! He's no lower than #2, arguably #1. In Fantasy leagues he will be one of the first 3 RB's drafted, no doubt about it. I don't think the author has ever seen B-West play!

Wow, is this guy smokin rope or what? Hey, houleness, i see you submitted this, tell me your not the author too, please?

All the posts thus far are dead on. And I second all their questions?

westbrook below addai give me a break

McNabbisking and SportsDevil,
This is a top 40 fantasy RB list, why can't you use rookies? If I went by that rule, Adrian Peterson wouldn't have been on the list last year! That wouldn't have been a very good list then, as he was one of the top backs in the league last year.

smc,
I see your point about Westbrook, but I can't see him being 1 or 2. Top 5 sure, but 1, now, you have to be kidding. He's really versatile and gets a ton of yards, but he's not getting any younger, and I expect some drop off this year.