Tournament Style Vote Off ( Day 2 ) -- NFL QB's -- Up now -- B. FARVE vs. A. Rodgers -- Pick the Winner

This is a simple tournament style vote off. What you do here is vote for the best QB of the pair that is up at that time. This is a tournament so vote for the top paring first the next match up will begin after 15 total votes, the first to 8 votes, or the leader at the 24th hour, whichever comes first.

Then move to the next pairing on the list and so on till the list is complete and then we start round two which I will post with the new match ups. I will Post the new match ups every day till we crown the CHAMPION.

Lets be friendly and honest here is the match up. The NAMES in CAPS are the winners of that match up move on to the next round. When you see a pairing with a CAPS winner move down to where there are two QB's in lower case letters and that is the one we will be voting on at that time. When the next round comes out it will be posted the same as this one but with round 2, then 3, then 4 and so on till we have our two SUPER BOWL QB's. Only vote for the one in session.

Let's keep it friendly, and tell your friends we are here and lets make this fun for everyone.

Now in session is: A. Rodgers vs B. Farve ---

J.CAMPBELL defeats T.Jackson --- (11-2) --- J. CAMPBELL WINS

T.ROMO defeats M.Hasselback --- (8 - 6) --- T. ROMO WINS

P.MANNING defeats T.Brady --- (9 - 7) --- P. MANNING WINS

B. FARVE defeats A. Rodgers --- (7 - 6) --- B. FARVE WINS

E.Manning vs. P.Rivers --- NOW IN SESSION

D.McNabb vs. C.Palmer

V.Young vs. D. Anderson

B.Rothlesburger vs. Trent Edwards

J.Garcia vs. A.Rodgers

K. Warner vs. J. Kitna

R. Grossman vs. D. Garrard

J. Cutler vs. J. Delhomme

D. Brees vs. M. Bulger

J. Russell vs. M. Schuab

85 Comments On: "Tournament Style Vote Off ( Day 2 ) -- NFL QB's -- Up now -- B. FARVE vs. A. Rodgers -- Pick the Winner"

 
My pick is Tom Brady

The Score is:

T. Brady over P. Manning --- 1 - 0

As muchas I love the Patriots, I'm goin with Manning

Hi WJ, I'm surprised, thought you would pick the other way. But I got you down for Manning.

The Score is:

T. Brady over P. Manning --- 1 - 1

Could this be our closest contest yet? What do you say Barkers?

"Cmon guys and gals this would be a great match up. We feel a high scoring shoot out. Something like that Cleveland vs Cincinnati game last year when defense just went out the window.

What do you guys think?

If the the over/under was 80, which way would you go? Lets say it is the final game of the season and both are playing for Home field advantage through out and Its an indoor game at Indy where the weather isn't a factor. Do you pick over or under at 80? and tell us with a -2pk spread, who would you pick in this game. All key players are healthy. Whew, boy, I'd love to be there for that game.

What do you guys think?

i gotta go with brady only cause he has more superbowls and has a better head to head record vs. manning!!!
oh! manning always had better receivers too!!!

Hi LIL, thanks for stopping in, I got you, Brady. Thanks for the vote.

The Score is:

T. Brady over P. Manning --- 2 - 1

manning

Good afternoon, WJ.... Manning it is.

The Score is:

T. Brady over P. Manning --- 2 - 2

Whoever wins this will win it all for the QB rankings, so isn't this really the championship?


You would think maybe your right, however, when I ran this last year on another site, neither one of these guys won. Its all comes down to favorites, match ups, and what regions of the country come to vote.

True, guss you can put McNabb in right now then

what do you think of the next match up?

When you have picked your winner in this vote off, go pick your favorite BEER, there is plenty to choose from at:

http://www.yardbarker.com/backyard/articles/LIST_The_SUDS_of_Summer_Domestic_Import_Style/293860

Pick your favorite, on us... Have a Great day...

CHEERS FOR NOW

P Manning over Brady smartest player in football

I agree with that statement Re: Manning being smartest, as a QB, I'd agree. There are others at their positions that are just as smart at their craft, the first two that jumped in my mind were, Jerry Rice and Marvin Harrison, their study of D's and DB's combined with their route running or pass patterns if you will, is and are out of this world. Just ask the QB's that throw to them or the defenders covering them.

Thanks for coming in deadred, I have you down for Manning. Now go have a BEER at

http://www.yardbarker.com/backyard/articles/LIST_The_SUDS_of_Summer_Domestic_Import_Style/293860

Pick your favorite, on us... Have a Great day...

CHEERS FOR NOW

Its a close one guys and gals. Manning takes over the lead.

The Score is:

P. Manning over T. Brady --- 3 - 2

wow!!!Tough one brady... sorry manning brady is more mobile..

Hi Reds1214, I got you down for Brady

We hav a tie game going here, its back and forth, we are now tied.

The Score is:

P. Manning over T. Brady --- 3 - 3

Manning, he basically runs that offense himself

Welcome peagle05, how r u today? Manning it is.

its all good, how's it goin?

The Score is:

P. Manning over T. Brady --- 4 - 3

Peyton is just more talented, and puts more work in.

More work behind the camera..haha. I'm a Giants fan and I'm sick of seeing the Manning bros!

your sick, imagine how Archie must feel. LOL

hey rhcp, how r u? Got you down with Manning.

Manning is opening up lead.....

The Score is:

P. Manning over T. Brady --- 5 - 3

Manning."coach on the field" But I dislike them both for torchin the Vikes secondary.Wait a min. doesnt everybody do that!With the exception of Eli Manning.

Manning threw 5 TD's against the Vikings last year! ... that really sucked.

manning for you...is that right?

Manning is great but Brady is this decade's Joe Cool however I think Manning is more of a pure QB so i'll take MANNING

JWW, got you for Manning

BRADY. Let's not forget that a year and a half ago Manning was regarded as one of the biggest choke artists in the league...puts up huge regular season numbers and folds in the playoffs. Manning won the superbowl with poor performances over The Bears (lead by the NFL's worse QB, Rex "the hot mess" Grossman) and a depleted Pats team. His team carried him through. The timeS Brady won he carried his team through and has proved time and again that he can get it done without stars around him.

your going with Brady I take it webkid?

Manning is opening up lead.....

The Score is:

P. Manning over T. Brady --- 8 - 4

Peyton for me...Brady will go down as a better QB because of his super bowl wins, but Peyton might be the best QB ever. He calls 73% of his own plays (because he can read a defense better than any QB in history) and his defense has never been as good as the Pats defense (most notably the playoff game vs. the Chiefs where neither team punted. The Colts scored 38 points, but only won by 1 touchdown because of their terrible defense)

Manning it is...

i'll go with Brady but its close

brady, you got it

I will have to go with Tom Brady. He's the best...period!

I got you with brady

even tho brady is a cheater, ill still pick him

brady it is