Will Tebow Be Able to Cut It In The NFL?

Last year, history was made in college football. And Gainesville, Florida couldn't be happier for it.

As the highly anticipated 2008 campaign approaches, much ado continues to surround Florida Gator sensation Tim Tebow. In 2007, Tebow became the only sophomore in college football history to win the Heisman Trophy. If his record-setting numbers on the field weren't enough to secure him the award, his off-the-field character made him the overwhelming favorite. Florida's golden boy has at least one, and likely two more years running Urban Meyer's high-powered offense. And if Tebow's performance to date isn't enough to make NFL general managers salivate, another season similar to his last could conceivably have teams out of contention throwing games for a chance to select him with their top pick. Sports talk shows in Jacksonville, Tampa and Miami consistently discuss the possibility of drafting Tebow. Easy, fellas, he's only a junior.

Most agree that Tebow's bruising style does not bode well for a lengthy or successful professional career. In the NFL, opposing defenses are bigger, quicker and stronger. Safeties lick their chops at the chance to flatten a quarterback heading in their direction. Even though the NFL goes out of its way to protect its quarterbacks, Tebow's game as it stands right now will at best lead to extended time on injured reserve and at worst, knock him out of the league. While the pros have featured their share of scrambling quarterbacks, Steve Young, Randall Cunningham and Donovan McNabb were never ones to run over defensive linemen.

Coming out of high school, many also questioned whether his game would succeed in the Southeastern Conference. Safe to say it has. His freshman campaign included several possessions where he scrambled to keep Florida drives alive, punishing would be tacklers along the way. Alongside Chris Leak, he played an integral role in their quest for a national championship. As a sophomore, Tebow's rushing stats were gaudy, penetrating the end zone twenty-two times. Tebow is cut from a different cloth. In only two years, he has become the poster child for college football while nearly single-handedly putting Florida back on the map as title contenders. His future holds an unforeseeable ceiling, as long as he can remain healthy.

Meyer has confessed to over-using Tebow last year. Gator fans nationwide cringed as Urban would call Tebow's number on short-yardage plays with leads late in the game. Last year, Tebow took a pounding, including a broken forearm against in-state rival Florida State. Tebow has never been one to slide tackle or avoid contact. In fact, he welcomes it. He runs head first into traffic with little regard for his health, or the health of those attempting to bring him down. So far, he's gotten the better end of the deal.

2008 will be different. No one expects Meyer to use Tebow in that same fashion. Adjustments will assuredly be made. With the addition of USC transfer Emmanuel Moody, as well as speedsters like Chris Rainey and Percy Harvin in the backfield, Tebow's rushing responsibilities should diminish significantly. While Tebow will still run the football, it's highly unlikely his rushing numbers will equal those of last year.

His performance over the next two years will either solidify his position as the top draft pick or increase skepticism about his style of play. Florida's fun and gun offense should yield flashy, aerial numbers to add to Tebow's resume. National title contention will attract even more attention, if that's possible. One thing for certain, Tebow is Meyer's boy. Coach Meyer will do whatever it takes to ensure his success at the next level. Modifying Tebow's game and winning at Florida are not mutually exclusive. So in that sense, he's a project. A more pass-happy Tim Tebow, mixed in with the occasional power rush, can still translate into success in the Swamp, and a less battered Timmy.

If Tebow keeps Florida in contention for another national title while remaining at Florida, and is once again invited to the Heisman ceremony, one would be hard-pressed to find a general manager in the league who wouldn't take a chance on Tebow with their top pick, even if they have no immediate need for a quarterback. While a Heisman trophy does not necessarily translate into success at the next level (insert Eric Crouch, Troy Smith, Danny Wuerffel or Gino Torretta reference here), none of those players won the award as a sophomore.

He's sturdy, he's smart, he's charismatic. He has the potential to become the face of most NFL franchises, and that sells. While Heisman Trophy winner Matt Leinart dropped to tenth in the 2006 draft, it is as likely that Tebow falls that far as it is to find pictures of him doing beer bongs on the internet. If the Atlanta Falcons are willing to mortgage their future on Matt Ryan, continued success for Tebow might mean he'd be able to name his own price, barring any immediate NFL rookie salary cap.

Tebow's success as an NFL quarterback is still speculation, although after only one full year at Florida, he has shown arm strength, leadership skills and unlimited potential. And while he might never become the next Dan Marino or Joe Montana, one gets the impression he'll be just fine calling plays and winning games at the next level.

43 Comments On: "Will Tebow Be Able to Cut It In The NFL?"

 
no chance. you gave examples already. tebow runs first and throws next. I think he has gotten better, but look at the qb's who have the same game but couldn't cut it. mike vick, aaron brooks, vince young,d. mcnabb. mcnabb is successful, but changed his game to a more pocket style. tebow reminds me of a more mobile daunte culpepper. good luck to him, i am a dolphins fan, so there is a good chance he could end up there, but i just dont know if his game translates to the nfl.

Free Agent,

Keep in mind I didn't say Tebow's game would necessarily translate to the next level. What I do believe, however, is that an NFL team will take a shot at him very high in the draft.

Tebow will be fine in the NFL. I play HS football at Nease, where Tebow played, and I saw first hand how hard a worker he is. He is so dedicated to football that he will not fail. He will be a great NFL player, I will tell you that right now.

Sorry TC, not a chance, he is way to inaccurate a passer and has no idea how to shift around in the pocket to avoid pressure. He may work hard but I haven't seen anything from him that shows me that he'll be any different than Alex Smith, or any other athletic QB who ran the spread in college.
The bigger question is with so many D-1 schools trying to run the spread offense, just where will the NFL QBs come from? All the great NFL QBs all came out of a pro-style offense in college, I don't see the NFL running the spread, the defenses are too fast and the coaches study too much film.

not fast enough for the running style qb which he is

TC, thanks for chiming in. His work ethic puts him ahead of most.

Cowboy, I'd give the kid two more years to work on his passing game. As you mention, the lack of quality QBs in the NFL is just one of the reasons I think he'll be selected high.

Birds, I'm a firm believer that we'll see a more pass-oriented Tebow in 2008.

Two more years? Doubtful. He'll be another Heisman winner that will be a bust in the pros, winning that thing is almost a sure kiss of death to a pro career. For every Carson Palmer there is a Gino Torretta, Eric Crouch, Andre Ware, Charlie Ward. . .the list goes on and on.

i don't see it......he is just that much better than the rest......the guy played a HS game here at Nease with a BROKEN LEG........he is so determined in everything he does, in one way or another, he will succeed in the NFL

all the qb's in the nfl work hard its their job....having the skill set and mentality to translate productivity onto the field has to come from natural talent, we saw byron leftwich have his linemen carry him up the field at Marshall and he is out of a job right now

he could be a good quarterback.. but anyone other than me think that he'll end up a fullback?
6'2, 238, has decent speed... it could happen

Cowboy, two questions for ya'. 1) Would you be entirely surprised if he stayed his senior year at Florida and 2) how high do you think he'll be drafted?

Peagle & OneandOnly, I don't see any NFL team switching his position.

they probably won't but im just sayin it could work

Entirely. Why stay at Florida? The charm of Gainseville?
If they look at him purely as a QB 3rd at best. He already has a bad shoulder and he will only take more pounding running the spread because Tebow is not smart enough to slide, he always wants to prove that he's tougher than the defensive player.
The best case scenario for him is to go in the later rounds, less pressure on him. The "slash" guys like Kordell Stewart, Randel-El, were all late round guys because teams saw their "potential" at postions other than QB and they were cheap. The thing that will really hurt him is Matt Jones, another mobile lefty with great size and athletic ability that had teams excited about his potential. Now Jones is a bust, on and off the field. Tebow may have better character than Jones but he does not have more athletic ability than Jones, that guy was a freak.
Am I right? Who knows, we'll see in a few years.

Big ups CowboyJoe. Good points.

I dont see him being anything than a has been when college is over then. He should stay for his senior year so he can get one extra year for his career.

In all honesty , I think Urban has pounded this guy so much he has possibly taken yrs off of his pro career. I have never seen a College QB take a pounding and dish the pounding as much as Tim has so far in his early career. If he plans on being at the next level and being successful .........he needs to tell Urban to trim the sneaks and direct runs off the playbook . Florida has other weapons on offense. Tim is a big kid , we all know that, but Urban needs to loosen up and think of this kids future.

QB is more about smarts than anything else... and he has the physical tools... this kid can get it done. Just let an NFL coach get their hands on him and see what Tebow can really do.

The kid is a football player.

if Vince Young can be a pro bowler, so can Tim Tebow.

ABSOLUTELY NOT!! Vince Young (college) was a on a complete different universe than Tebow.

Tebow is quite possibly the most overrated QB in all of modern day football.

you're kidding right?

A very well written and thoughtful article. I couldn't agree more with just about every point you made. We watched Tebow play at Nease in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida, and honestly, the kid just hasn't changed all that much as far as his view on his role in the game. I doubt he'll leave UF without a degree.

I think Tim Tebow can cut it in the NFL. I just don't want him drafted into a bad team.

Cowboy, I don't think you can compare him to a Stewart or a Randle-El. Tebow's not exactly mobile or swift, but rather bull-dozing. Regarding him staying in school, let's keep in mind this is a kid that travels overseas in the off-season to help the less fortunate. This is a kid who refused Playboy's all-american invitation. I just don't see him leaving early.

FlaBuck, I do think that Meyer has told Tebow to slide more and avoid contact. I just don't think he listens. I do expect less pounding this year.

CWitt, the kid threw and rushed for 20+ TDs last season. That's the first that's ever been done in the history of college football. How can you say he's overrated?

Ivy, thanks for stopping by. I think those that follow him the closest agree that he'll be at UF all four years.

yeah, Tebow is definitely not overrated

Two words - tight end.

I think he will be good he showed he can play, he works hard and looks mentally strong enough to make it in the NFL he wont be a bust

I will just leave it at this, he will not be a good NFL Qaurterback... Now FB, TE,... MLB. lol Idk

One & Chris,

Honestly, what's more likely. That Tebow plays in the NFL as a tight end or a quarterback?

I think he will be a QB definately.............

I haven't not seen if he can be a drop-back/pocket passing QB to make that judgment. Based on what I have seen and his ability, if he can't be a QB, he'd make a fine tight end.

I am amazed at some of the comments on this page. Have the people who claim he cannot pass and say he is a run first QB watched him play at all. Did you watch him play last season? Nationally, Tebow finished second in passing efficiency, 10th in total offense, second in points responsible (25.38 per game) and third in rushing touchdowns.
Oh, and by the way, he did become the first sophomore in history to win the Heisman Trophy and he did it in only his first season as a starter. I think Tebow will continue to improve and if he keeps his work ethic and determination to make it happen. I think he will be just fine at the next level. Who knows if he will become a hall of famer. Bottom line is I believe he will continue to improve. He has a high ceiling, so improvement will come. That will be impressive given what he did last year in his first year as a starter. So just go take a look at his numbers from last year befor making statements like some of the ones in this thread. Oh, and by the way; in his role in 2006 he came in to be a glorified full back. So I think he can take what punishment is given out. He did have a couple of injuries last season, but aside from the Georgia game he seemed to play just fine. He cannot help the defense was full of freshman last season. Had the Gators had the defense I believe they would have been undefeated last season. I am a Gator fan, but he numbers don't lie on Tebow.

Albert to the rescue!

Tebow is a legitamate NFL prospect at QB dont forget last year was his first year as a full time qb in college and he can work on his mechanics and become a more accurate passer and with his wheels look out

I think he is a very good QB............I just don't agree with Urban pounding the crap out of him with short runs over and over . I am serious..........he will not last long at the next level if his body is already beat up. Yes he has the cliam........"Superman"...............but seriously.

Now that Moody is eligible, I doubt Tebow will get as many carries.

He's the quarterback you want your daughter to marry.


IFChris,

I think that's key... I highly doubt Tebow will carry the load as he did last year. At least, let's hope not.

forget my daughter hes the qb i wanna marry lol jk

Of course he will. He'll be a great quarterback!

For everyone who's not a believer...Check yourself...Tebow (i hate talkin about this guy) Has only been the QB for one year, He hasn't even bloomed yet. Give him a chance to learn football first...He's only running the plays that are called. Run first pass later, You only take what the Defense gives you. Believe this----First Rd Draft Pick----It just seems were just judging the Book by the cover or the first Chapter...CHECKMATE

Rondo, what surprises me is that so many think he won't be. You've seen the comments.

Checkmate, thanks for agreeing.

Anything is Possible

You guys really don't think that someone like Del Rio wouldn't want Tebow on his team. Come on. Garrard will be into his contract by then and I could see Tebow definitely not going early in the first round. He's from the jax area. They need to sell tix and you can bet that the Tebow jersey would be right up there with Bush's was at New Orleans. the league will milk this guy to be the face of the NFlL, especially with the troubles they've had with image lately, i.e. Michael Vick. You don't need to have a phenomenal arm to make it in the NFL. You need a good team. Plus, Jax loves to draft Florida players.

Your comment:



Featured Stories Today
 
Meeting the Hand of God
I have no idea why it took me so long to load this -- but the video below is one of the greatest...
Utah, Enjoying Ohio State, in Illinois
A lack of scoring? Who cares if Johnny Utah is...
The Boston Red Sox: Next "Evil Empire"?
Those are harsh words to come Boston's way considering any comparison to the Bronx Bombers is nigh...
Highlights of Vitali Klitschko pummeling Samuel Peter
If you're from Germany or Ukraine and a big fan of the Klitschko Brothers, then it was probably one ...
The Herschel Walker Trade on October 12, 1989
Today's FSD History Flashback for October 12 reflects on what many view as the most lopsided trade...

Top 10 Related Stories