Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

Phillies trade proposal sends beloved outfielder to Royals

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Matthew Sullivan | Last updated Apr 1, 2025 7:18 PM ET

The Philadelphia Phillies won their Opening Day game. The victory over the Washington Nationals featured incredible highlights and a rough day at the plate for multiple Phillies. One of the players who struggled is the subject of this trade proposal.

Brandon Marsh watched as multiple strikes went down the middle and struck out four times in all four of his at-bats. He struck out in key spots and was bailed out by a passed ball two batters later.

In this trade pitch, Marsh is traded to the Kansas City Royals. Marsh would likely net the Phillies a solid return and major league-ready talent. A potential deal could include outfielder Hunter Renfroe and pitcher Steven Zobac.

His strikeout issues may be too much for the Phillies and could lead Marsh to end up on the trade block. Marsh's struggles have stretched throughout his MLB career. While he's improved, he's still too patient and watches too many pitches.

After a Marsh trade, the Phillies would likely have Johan Rojas as the full-time center fielder, with another addition competing for the spot. It could also open the door to acquiring a top-flight center fielder like Luis Robert Jr. in a trade.

Marsh has a few years of control left and would likely net the Phillies a good return. With options in-house like Rojas and likely available center fielders on the market, the Phillies deciding they've seen enough of Marsh isn't out of the question.

This trade pitch sends Marsh to the Royals, where he could start every day in center field. The Phillies, meanwhile, would have Rojas or a trade acquisition take over in center field.

Marsh had many great moments for the Phillies during his tenure. If he is traded, there will be some lingering attachment to what could've been.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: