Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
When Should the White Sox Trade Luis Robert Jr.?
Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images

Not everyone is on board with trading him, but there is only one player left that can return legitimate prospect capital to the rebuilding Chicago White Sox organization if they decide to make the move.

His name is Luis Robert Jr., and his trade market is the hottest topic among fans right with three weeks until the start of the season.

When healthy and at his best, as he was in 2023, Robert is a superstar talent. A threat to hit 30+ home runs, steal 30+ bases, and play elite defense in center field. The problem is that’s the only full season of his career in which he has played more than 100 games. Yeah, that is not ideal.

His trade market is tricky to figure out as the White Sox need to continue stockpiling talent for the future, but he’s the only player in their current lineup capable of producing elite numbers.

Talks around camp this spring in regards to front office moves center around when a possible Robert trade could take place.

The hot start to the spring he’s having right now is further bringing out these conversations. Given that the White Sox traded Dylan Cease just two weeks before the season started last year, there is reason to consider that happening again with another star.

Through his first 16 plate appearances this spring, Robert has recorded six hits, two home runs, and two walks while displaying better discipline than ever at the plate. More importantly, he’s healthy.

No team was willing to meet the team’s asking price this offseason, but that could shift quickly with his proof of health and performance. Some teams may grow eager to make a splash as well if they’re not feeling set with the offensive production currently on their roster.

With two more years beyond 2025 of club options at $20 million, the White Sox have the ability to take their time finding value in a deal. However, another injury-riddled season and that seemingly team-friendly contract won’t look all that friendly anymore.

Trying to guess when the move gets made is nearly impossible, but there are options at hand, while the timing will depend on his performance and his health.

Option 1: Sell high now

The White Sox could capitalize on Robert looking good through a week of spring games and try to get a tad more than they would’ve a month ago from a team in need of more offensive juice before the season gets rolling.

This would look something like the Cease deal in which the White Sox jump on an opportunity with a team in need but probably wouldn’t get quite the value fans would be hoping for in a trade.

An already rough lineup without Robert’s talent would be difficult to head into the season with, but could push the farm system towards being the best in baseball.

Option 2: Wait for a strong month or two, then capitalize

This could look similar to the Luis Arraez trade last season, which also involved the Padres, like the Cease deal.

If the White Sox are willing to bet on Robert’s hot start carrying over into the regular season, they could target a contender off to a slow start for a trade. For instance, if a team like the Phillies, with clear World Series aspirations and a need for outfield help, struggles out of the gate, Robert after a strong April could make sense.

However, if Robert struggles out of the gate or worse, gets hurt, this option quickly falls off the table. It’s an ideal scenario, but one less common than the next.

Option 3: Best value possible at the deadline

The most common outcome for clear trade candidates once the season gets rolling is a deal at the deadline that involves as many teams as possible in negotiations.

Robert’s first half would determine what type of return Chicago would get back, but a number of teams would hypothetically be involved here. If he has a big first half and stays healthy, many contenders will want to add a center fielder with potentially two and a half years of control.

But if he gets hurt again, the White Sox may be forced to sell low in order to get whatever value is left rather than picking up his $20 million option for 2026.

The range of outcomes is drastically different in this circumstance, but it does feel more likely than an early deal.

Option 4: Hold until the offseason or beyond…

Maybe the White Sox are surprisingly good and decide Robert is a core piece of the future…yeah it’s not likely but not impossible.

There’s also the chance that Robert struggles enough that his value isn’t high enough to trade for an appropriate price but also isn’t low enough for the White Sox to let him walk. It’s an odd predicament, but one that could happen.

There could be a situation like the Crochet deal, but if Robert has a big season like Crochet did last year, the third option seems more likely, given his track record.

Moving Forward


Chicago White Sox center fielder Luis Robert Jr. puts on his glove before a game against the St. Louis Cardinals on July 8, 2023, at Guaranteed Rate Field in Chicago. (John J. Kim/Chicago Tribune/Tribune News Service via Getty Images)

Trying to time out this trade will not be easy for GM Chris Getz and the rest of the front office, but it does seem like a matter of when, not if, with a few weeks left until the season kicks off.

Imagining this offense without Robert is scary, but the future continues to look brighter, and another couple of talented prospects would help further that.

The most likely outcome is a deadline deal, but that hinges entirely on Robert staying healthy and productive.

This article first appeared on Just Baseball and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Yankees Predicted to Land Former Cubs' World Series Champion
MLB

Yankees Predicted to Land Former Cubs' World Series Champion

There are few Chicago Cubs players who have captured the hearts of the fans more than Anthony Rizzo did during his time with the organization. Even after not playing for the Cubs since the 2021 season, fans in Chicago love the former star slugger. Rizzo also was a huge part of leading the Cubs to a World Series win back in 2016. As of right now, Rizzo still happens to be a free agent. He is not the superstar that he once was in Chicago, but there are teams who could use depth around the league. Could that landing spot simply be re-signing with the New York Yankees for another run? When the Cubs moved on from Rizzo ahead of the 2021 MLB trade deadline, they shipped him to the Yankees. He has played the last three and a half years in New York. Zachary D. Rymer of Bleacher Report has now predicted that Rizzo will end up back with the Yankees in 2025. "There's been little action on the 35-year-old Rizzo throughout the offseason, yet he was adamant last month about wanting to continue his career," Rymer wrote. "Though he hasn't been the same player since suffering a concussion in 2023, the three-time All-Star may find a fit with a team in need of a left-handed bat at first base or designated hitter. Bold Prediction: Rizzo returns to the New York Yankees to help spell Giancarlo Stanton." Stanton's injury could help Rizzo find his way back to New York. It's possible that the Yankees could lose Stanton for the season due to his elbow injury. During the 2024 season, Rizzo hit eight home runs to go along with 35 RBI and slashed .228/.301/.335. He played in 92 games.

Steelers lose their third free agent of the week to same team following departure of once-promising trade acquisition
NFL

Steelers lose their third free agent of the week to same team following departure of once-promising trade acquisition

The Pittsburgh Steelers acquired Mike Williams from the New York Jets at the 2024 trade deadline. The move provided immediate dividends, as the Steelers won a game against the Washington Commanders thanks to a catch from Mike Williams in his first career game with the Steelers. Unfortunately, that was the highlight of his time in Pittsburgh ,and now he's headed back to where it all started... Chargers sign third former Steeler of the Week, WR Mike Williams "BREAKING: The Chargers are signing WR Mike Williams to a 1-year deal worth up to $6M as he returns to Los Angeles — where he spent the first seven years of his career, sources tell NFL on FOX. Williams is back catching passes from Justin Herbert." - Jordan Schultz, Fox Sports In case you missed the first two, Donte Jackson and Najee Harris headed to the West Coast earlier in the week. Jackson will be a bit of an acquired taste in Los Angeles and for HC Jim Harbaugh. After receiving him in a trade that sent Diontae Jackson packing, many were skeptical of trading for an often-injured corner who is smaller and slighter than what the Steelers normally covet. Najee Harris averaged less than four yards per carry during his time with the Steelers, and he never had that second gear that Pittsburgh saw at Alabama. However, Harris also never played with a good offensive line and was asked to be the bell cow for an offense that changed running schemes multiple times. And still, he reached over 1,000 yards and five-plus rushing TDs every year in Pittsburgh, all the while not missing a start, much less a game. Chargers HC Jim Harbaugh has a type at RB, and Najee Harris fits that type. A road grader with a ton of durability and power, he’s exactly what the Chargers want their lead back to look like. So it’s a move that brings Najee Harris back to his home state of California and brings the Los Angeles Chargers closer to being the offense they want to be: A smashmouth team that throws off play action. As for Mike Williams, the familiarity with the Chargers and the fact that the team still has a need at the WR position made this move easy to see coming.

Vikings Lose Former 1st-Round Pick to Chiefs: Report
NFL

Vikings Lose Former 1st-Round Pick to Chiefs: Report

The Minnesota Vikings bolstered their defensive front in free agency, signing Jonathan Allen (three years, $51 million) and Javon Hargrave (two years, $30 million) to lucrative contracts. It was a significant investment for the Vikings, who ranked 28th in spending on the defensive line with just $11.7 million spent on five rostered defensive linemen in 2024. That unit provided plenty of value, allowing the second-fewest rushing yards in the league, but offered more to be desired in the pass rush. It led to the Vikings selling out to create pressure, blitzing at the highest rate in the NFL. The desire to improve the defensive line has led several meaningful contributors to reach free agency, but there is still the possibility of re-signing as depth. However, that won't be the case with a former first-round pick who signed with the Kansas City Chiefs on Day 5 of free agency. NFL Network's Ian Rapoport reported on Friday, March 14, that Jerry Tillery is signing a one-year deal with the Chiefs. The 28th overall pick by the Los Angeles Chargers in the 2019 draft, Tillery didn't live up to his draft status initially and was released after three seasons. He spent two seasons with the Las Vegas Raiders before signing a one-year, $3.8 million deal with the Vikings last season. Tillery played every game and made 11 starts, playing the third-most snaps (482) on the defensive front last season. He totaled 19 pressures and 19 total tackles, according to Pro Football Focus (PFF). Fellow starter Jonathan Bullard remains a free agent while nose tackle Harrison Phillips is poised to start with Allen and Hargrave on each of his shoulders. Bullard and Tillery's combined 25 total pressures pale in comparison to Allen and Hargrave's 113 combined pressures from the 2023 season. Jihad Ward, who played 452 snaps last season, is also still a free agent. Meanwhile, the Vikings have retained Jalen Redmond and Levi-Drake Rodriguez as developmental pieces.

NFL

Insider questions if Aaron Rodgers will respect ‘back up QB’ Kevin O’Connell, Vikings leadership

The Minnesota Vikings have made multiple moves in the early stages of free agency to strengthen some of their weaknesses. They have signed a pair of offensive linemen from the Indianapolis Colts to help protect their quarterback and give their running game a boost. They have also added a pair of defensive linemen to improve their toughness. However, there are questions about the backup quarterback position that general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah and head coach Kevin O’Connell may have to address. The Vikings are planning to hand their QB1 position to J.J. McCarthy. He was the No. 10 pick overall in last year’s draft, and after making a positive impression on O’Connell and the Vikings coaching staff in the offseason and the early stages of training camp, McCarthy suffered a torn meniscus that cost him the 2024 season. The belief is that he will be ready to go this summer, but there are no guarantees. Even if McCarthy is healthy, there are legitimate questions about the Vikings’ backup quarterback position. Last year’s starter Sam Darnold has signed with the Seattle Seahawks, and Daniel Jones left through free agency to join the Indianapolis Colts. Bringing in an aging Aaron Rodgers has been mentioned, but it could lead to problems because of Rodgers’ status within the NFL and his reputation as something of a diva. Would Rodgers work well under O’Connell and Vikings coaches? Rodgers is one of the most accomplished quarterbacks in NFL history. The 41-year-old is a 4-time NFL Most Valuable Player and a 10-time Pro Bowl quarterback. He won the Super Bowl XLIV MVP award and he is a sure-fire Hall of Famer. He played 18 years with the Green Bay Packers before spending the last 2 seasons with the New York Jets. NFL insider Diana Russini of The Athletic questioned the kind of fit Rodgers would be within the Vikings organization. While O’Connell is extremely well thought of for the job he has done in his first 3 seasons as Minnesota’s head coach, he was a backup quarterback in his playing days. Would Rodgers have respect for O’Connell’s position since he has accomplished so much more in his career than O’Connell did in his career? Josh McCown is the quarterbacks coach for the Vikings and while he had a decent NFL career as a quarterback, it doesn’t compare to Rodgers’ accomplishments. Would Rodgers listen to the suggestions of O’Connell and McCown? While there are reasons to question the Vikings’ need for Rodgers, the only other quarterback on the Minnesota roster besides McCarthy is Brett Rypien. He did not throw a pass last year and his experience is quite limited.