Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Biggest all-time busts and missteps of NBA free agency
After signing a huge deal with the New York Knicks, Joakim Noah had an awful, injury-plagued 2016-17 season and got suspended for 20 games for violating the NBA's drug policy. Jasen Vinlove/USA TODAY Sports

Biggest all-time busts and missteps of NBA free agency

The history of NBA free agency features plenty hits and misses. The following 25 signings are some of the worst in the history of NBA free agency. None of the following lived up to the hefty contracts that were signed, and the teams who inked these players regretted it one form or fashion when it was all said and done.

 
1 of 25

1996: SuperSonics sign Jim McIlvaine for seven years, $33.6 million

1996: SuperSonics sign Jim McIlvaine for seven years, $33.6 million
Otto Greule Jr. / Getty Images

Seattle was looking to take the next step after making it to the NBA Finals in 1996. All the Sonics needed was a center, so they thought. McIlvaine was signed from the Bullets after two seasons for a lucrative deal despite averaging just 2.3 points and 2.9 rebounds in 14.9 minutes per game. He spent only two seasons as a starter for the SuperSonics, averaging just 3.8 points and 18 minutes per game in his best season.

 
2 of 25

1997: Grizzlies sign Bryant Reeves for six years, $61.8 million

1997: Grizzlies sign Bryant Reeves for six years, $61.8 million
Rocky Widner / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

"Big Country" Bryant Reeves was awarded a huge contract after only two seasons in Vancouver, as the former Oklahoma State star looked like a budding NBA center. After averaging more than 16 points per game in his first year of the contract, Reeves went into decline. He was out of the league following the 2000-01 season.

 
3 of 25

1997: SuperSonics sign Vin Baker for seven years, $86 million

1997: SuperSonics sign Vin Baker for seven years, $86 million
Brian Bahr / Getty Images

Baker signed with Seattle after getting traded from the Bucks. While the move worked out for the SuperSonics in the first year, as Baker averaged 19.2 points and made an All-Star appearance, he played only 34 of 50 games in a shortened season the following year and couldn't keep up his early-career pace. He was traded to the Celtics in 2002.

 
4 of 25

1999: Suns sign Anfernee Hardaway for seven years, $86 million

1999: Suns sign Anfernee Hardaway for seven years, $86 million
Rocky Widner / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

A star early in his career with Orlando, Hardaway signed a lucrative deal in Phoenix to create an impressive backcourt with Jason Kidd. Injuries clouded the promise of the pairing, particularly for Hardaway, who played only four games in 2000-01 due to a knee injury, and he was never the same after that season.

 
5 of 25

2002: Mavericks sign Raef LaFrentz for seven years, $70 million

2002: Mavericks sign Raef LaFrentz for seven years, $70 million
Nathaniel S. Butler / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

LaFrentz averaged 13 points, 7.7 rebounds and 2.5 blocked shocks during his first four NBA season before signing a $70 million contract with Dallas. He averaged only 9.3 points, 4.8 rebounds and 1.3 blocks in 2002-03 before getting traded to Boston the following year. His career ended unceremoniously in Portland following the 2007-08 season, spending time coming off the bench and battling injury over his final years.

 
6 of 25

2004: Trail Blazers sign Darius Miles for six years, $48 million

2004: Trail Blazers sign Darius Miles for six years, $48 million
Sam Forencich / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Portland saw the potential in the former third overall pick, giving Miles a huge contract in 2004. Locker room controversy hung over his first season with the team, and Miles played only 40 games the following year before undergoing microfracture surgery on his right knee. He missed two full seasons and played only 34 games in 2008-09 before his career ended.

 
7 of 25

2004: Mavericks sign Erick Dampier for seven years, $70 million

2004: Mavericks sign Erick Dampier for seven years, $70 million
Rocky Widner / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Dampier had a career-high 12.3 points and 12 rebounds in 2003-04 before being sent to Dallas from the Warriors in a sign-and-trade. He averaged only 9.2 points and 8.5 rebounds in his first season with the Mavs before his stats started to plummet. Over six years in Dallas, Dampier averaged just 6.5 points, 7.6 rebounds and 1.3 blocks per game.

 
8 of 25

2005: Knicks sign Jerome James for five years, $30 million

2005: Knicks sign Jerome James for five years, $30 million
Steve Freeman / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

James cashed in with the Knicks after a strong playoff showing with Seattle in 2005. He served as a bench player in his first two seasons in New York, averaging just 7.9 minutes over 86 games. He suffered through injury the next two years with the Knicks, playing a total of four games.

 
9 of 25

2005: Knicks sign Eddy Curry for six years, $60 million

2005: Knicks sign Eddy Curry for six years, $60 million
Rocky Widner / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Curry was traded from Chicago to New York and awarded a $60 million contract by the Knicks. His production was up and down during his first three years of the deal, though the team and fans weren't exactly thrilled with Curry's rebounding and defense. He played only 10 games over the next two seasons in New York due to weight and knee issues and didn't play at all during 2010-11.

 
10 of 25

2005: Cavaliers sign Larry Hughes for five years, $70 million

2005: Cavaliers sign Larry Hughes for five years, $70 million
Lisa Blumenfeld / Getty Images

Hughes averaged 22 points and a league-leading 2.9 steals per game in 2004-05 before signing in Cleveland to join LeBron James in 2005. Injuries plagued his Cavs career, which lasted two-plus years, and Hughes averaged only 14.3 points per game with the team.

 
11 of 25

2005: Bucks sign Bobby Simmons for five years, $47 million

2005: Bucks sign Bobby Simmons for five years, $47 million
Gary Dineen / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Simmons had a breakout year with the Clippers in 2004-05, winning the Most Improved Player Award. He signed with the Bucks in the offseason and continued to perform relatively well in 2005-06 before an ankle injury sidelined him for all of the following season. Simmons served as mostly a bench player for the rest of his career, including one more season in Milwaukee in which he averaged just 7.6 points per game.

 
12 of 25

2006: Bulls sign Ben Wallace for four years, $60 million

2006: Bulls sign Ben Wallace for four years, $60 million
Gary Dineen / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

An elite defensive player and four-time All-Star in Detroit, Wallace signed a huge contract age 32 in Chicago. He suffered through knee issues and failed to last two full seasons in Chicago.

 
13 of 25

2006: Knicks sign Jared Jeffries for five years, $30 million

2006: Knicks sign Jared Jeffries for five years, $30 million
Nathaniel S. Butler / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

The Knicks signed Jeffries away from Washington after he emerged as a starter for the Wizards. Jeffries suffered a wrist injury in his first season and was eventually relegated to part-time duty. The price tag was hefty for a player who averaged just 4.3 points per game in three-plus seasons with the Knicks.

 
14 of 25

2007: Magic sign Rashard Lewis for six years, $118 million

2007: Magic sign Rashard Lewis for six years, $118 million
Fernando Medina / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Lewis was a key contributor for the Magic early in his contract after being moved in a sign-and-trade from Seattle, but his play quickly declined after two seasons. Averaging only 12.2 points per game for the Magic in early 2010-11, he was traded to Washington for Gilbert Arenas. Lewis hasn't played since 2013-14.

 
15 of 25

2008: 76ers sign Elton Brand for five years, $82 million

2008: 76ers sign Elton Brand for five years, $82 million
Rocky Widner / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Despite playing only eight games in his final season with the Clippers, Philadelphia handed Brand a huge five-year contract. He hurt his shoulder in his first season with the 76ers and averaged only 13.3 points and 7.4 rebounds per game in four seasons before getting waived.

 
16 of 25

2008: Bobcats sign Emeka Okafor for six years, $72 million

2008: Bobcats sign Emeka Okafor for six years, $72 million
Streeter Lecka / Getty Images

Charlotte locked up its former second overall pick with a huge contract after four seasons in the NBA. His play declined in his first season of the deal, averaging 13.2 points and 10.1 rebounds, before getting traded to New Orleans for Tyson Chandler.

 
17 of 25

2009: Pistons sign Ben Gordon for five years, $55 million

2009: Pistons sign Ben Gordon for five years, $55 million
Issac Baldizon / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Detroit made headlines in the 2009 offseason by signing Gordon and Charlie Villanueva. Neither move worked out. Gordon worked off the bench as a sixth man but never played more than 62 games in a season over his three years in Detroit. After averaging 18.5 points per game over his first five years in Chicago, Gordon's average dropped to just 12.4 points as his three-point percentage dwindled.

 
18 of 25

2009: Raptors sign Hedo Turkoglu for five years, $53 million

2009: Raptors sign Hedo Turkoglu for five years, $53 million
Layne Murdoch / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Turkoglu lasted only one year in Toronto after an off-court incident in which he was seen at a night club after missing a game with a stomach virus. The relationship between team and player soured, resulting in a trade to Phoenix after only one year. Turkoglu also declined on the court, averaging only 11.3 points per game after averaging 16.8 points in 2008-09 with Orlando.

 
19 of 25

2010: Knicks sign Amar'e Stoudemire for five years, $100 million

2010: Knicks sign Amar'e Stoudemire for five years, $100 million
Nathaniel S. Butler / National Basketball Association / Getty Images

Stoudemire looked like a good fit in New York, reuniting with former head coach Mike D'Antoni and having arguably the best year of his career in his first season with the team. His play declined the following year in a lockout-shortened season before injuries hindered the rest of his career.

 
20 of 25

2013: Pistons sign Josh Smith for four years, $54 million

2013: Pistons sign Josh Smith for four years, $54 million
Mike Ehrmann / Getty Images

Smith didn't even last two seasons with Detroit, as he was waived in December of his second season and picked up by Houston. He played only one more season in the NBA.

 
21 of 25

2014: Hornets sign Lance Stephenson for three years, $27 million

2014: Hornets sign Lance Stephenson for three years, $27 million
Streeter Lecka / Getty Images

Stephenson finished second in the NBA Most Improved Player voting in 2014 and was rewarded with a nice deal in Charlotte. He had an injury-plagued 2014-15 season with the Hornets, serving mostly off the bench. Stephenson was traded to the Clippers after only one season.

 
22 of 25

2015: Mavericks sign Wesley Matthews for four years, $70 million

2015: Mavericks sign Wesley Matthews for four years, $70 million
Richard Mackson / USA Today Sports Images

Dallas would probably like a do-over on this move, especially as the Mavericks find themselves in rebuilding mode. Matthews has averaged only 12.9 points in three seasons with the Mavs.

 
23 of 25

2016: Grizzlies sign Chandler Parsons for four years, $94 million

2016: Grizzlies sign Chandler Parsons for four years, $94 million
Jerome Miron / USA Today Sports Images

Parsons left Dallas to sign a huge deal in Memphis, only to tear his meniscus in his left knee after having the same issue on his right knee in 2015-16. He played only 34 games in his first season with the Grizzlies, averaging 6.2 points per game, and followed up by averaging 7.9 points in just 36 games in the second year, starting just eight games. The knee issues don't create much optimism for the future of the deal.

 
24 of 25

2016: Lakers sign Timofey Mozgov for four years, $60 million

2016: Lakers sign Timofey Mozgov for four years, $60 million
Gary A. Vasquez / USA Today Sports Images

L.A. curiously backed up the Brink's truck for Mozgov, making him the team's starting center. He averaged only 7.4 points and 4.9 rebounds per game before getting benched late in the year. Mozgov was traded to the Nets following the season, along with D'Angelo Russell.

 
25 of 25

2016: Knicks sign Joakim Noah for four years, $72 million

2016: Knicks sign Joakim Noah for four years, $72 million
Andy Marlin / USA Today Sports Images

Noah has been a whipping boy in the media in New York, though it's not as if his decline was unpredictable. He played only 29 games and averaged just 4.3 points in his final season with Chicago before going to the Knicks. A shoulder injury and 20-game suspension for violating the league's anti-drug policy in the first year was followed by a falling out with the franchise in 2017-18.

Seth Trachtman

Seth Trachtman is a sportswriter, digital marketer, and fantasy sports expert based in St. Louis, Missouri. He’s a two-time winner of the Tout Wars Fantasy Baseball Expert’s League, and his work has appeared in hundreds of fantasy baseball and fantasy football newsstand and online publications

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Former Lakers draft pick showcasing potential with dominant performances
NBA

Former Lakers draft pick showcasing potential with dominant performances

Jalen Hood-Schifino’s NBA journey has been anything but smooth. After being selected 17th overall by the Los Angeles Lakers in the 2023 NBA Draft, his rookie season was derailed by injuries, significantly stalling his development. His time in Los Angeles ended abruptly when he was included in the blockbuster trade that sent Luka Doncic to the Lakers and Anthony Davis to the Dallas Mavericks. Hood-Schifino was shipped to the Utah Jazz as part of the deal — only to be swiftly waived. Now, the 21-year-old guard is getting a fresh start with the Philadelphia 76ers, signing a two-way contract on Feb. 28. While he has yet to debut for the Sixers, he has been making an impact in the G League with the Delaware Blue Coats, showcasing the talent that once made him a first-round pick. Through his first three games with Delaware, Hood-Schifino has averaged an impressive 27 points and four assists while shooting 50 percent from three-point range — all in just 25.3 minutes per game. His last two outings have been particularly dominant, with back-to-back 30-plus-point performances and 12 made three-pointers over the three-game span. His ability to score at all three levels, combined with his 6-foot-6 frame, has made him a tough matchup for G League defenders. This is not the first time he has excelled at this level; last season, he played 15 games for the South Bay Lakers, averaging 22 points, 4.8 rebounds, and 5.5 assists while shooting 43.2 percent from deep. His biggest concern has been his health, but now that he is fully fit, his offensive skill set is on display. Even when healthy last season, Hood-Schifino struggled to earn minutes in the Lakers’ rotation as the team continuously reshaped its roster in pursuit of playoff success. However, with the 76ers’ season not going as planned, there could be an opportunity for him to get NBA minutes before the regular season concludes. As Philadelphia evaluates its roster for next season, Hood-Schifino’s strong G League production suggests he may still have a future at the NBA level. If he continues his impressive play, he could force his way into a role in Philadelphia or elsewhere.

Steelers lose their third free agent of the week to same team following departure of once-promising trade acquisition
NFL

Steelers lose their third free agent of the week to same team following departure of once-promising trade acquisition

The Pittsburgh Steelers acquired Mike Williams from the New York Jets at the 2024 trade deadline. The move provided immediate dividends, as the Steelers won a game against the Washington Commanders thanks to a catch from Mike Williams in his first career game with the Steelers. Unfortunately, that was the highlight of his time in Pittsburgh ,and now he's headed back to where it all started... Chargers sign third former Steeler of the Week, WR Mike Williams "BREAKING: The Chargers are signing WR Mike Williams to a 1-year deal worth up to $6M as he returns to Los Angeles — where he spent the first seven years of his career, sources tell NFL on FOX. Williams is back catching passes from Justin Herbert." - Jordan Schultz, Fox Sports In case you missed the first two, Donte Jackson and Najee Harris headed to the West Coast earlier in the week. Jackson will be a bit of an acquired taste in Los Angeles and for HC Jim Harbaugh. After receiving him in a trade that sent Diontae Jackson packing, many were skeptical of trading for an often-injured corner who is smaller and slighter than what the Steelers normally covet. Najee Harris averaged less than four yards per carry during his time with the Steelers, and he never had that second gear that Pittsburgh saw at Alabama. However, Harris also never played with a good offensive line and was asked to be the bell cow for an offense that changed running schemes multiple times. And still, he reached over 1,000 yards and five-plus rushing TDs every year in Pittsburgh, all the while not missing a start, much less a game. Chargers HC Jim Harbaugh has a type at RB, and Najee Harris fits that type. A road grader with a ton of durability and power, he’s exactly what the Chargers want their lead back to look like. So it’s a move that brings Najee Harris back to his home state of California and brings the Los Angeles Chargers closer to being the offense they want to be: A smashmouth team that throws off play action. As for Mike Williams, the familiarity with the Chargers and the fact that the team still has a need at the WR position made this move easy to see coming.

New York Yankees Get Excellent News Out of Gerrit Cole's Elbow Surgery
MLB

New York Yankees Get Excellent News Out of Gerrit Cole's Elbow Surgery

The New York Yankees got devastating news this week when it was revealed that ace Gerrit Cole would miss the entire season because of an elbow injury. However, if you're looking silver linings, the Yankees got great news out of the surgery, Per Bryan Hoch of MLB.com: Gerrit Cole’s UCL surgery included internal bracing, according to the Yankees, which can reduce inflammation and speed recovery time. Generally speaking, this could mean he is closer to a 12-month recovery than if he had the procedure with the traditional method. Given when the injury occurred, there is even a slight chance that Cole could be ready for Opening Day in 2026. For example, Spencer Strider had Tommy John surgery early in the 2024 season and is set to come back by late April of this year. Lucas Giolito of the Red Sox had internal bracing done last spring training and was on track for an Opening Day return this year until he injured his hamstring. The 34-year-old Cole is one of the best pitchers of his era, having gone 153-80 over a 12-year career with the Pittsburgh Pirates, Houston Astros and Yankees. A six-time All-Star, Cole won the American League Cy Young Award in 2023 and has won two ERA titles. He dealt with elbow issues last season but returned to go 8-5 in 17 starts as the Yankees won the American League pennant. He pitched just 95 innings for the season, striking out 99. The Yankees will open up the season on March 27 at home against the Milwaukee Brewers.

NHL insider reveals young star traded to Buffalo was 'devastated' in debut
NHL

NHL insider reveals young star traded to Buffalo was 'devastated' in debut

Josh Norris had made a home in the NHL in Ottawa, and after the trade to Buffalo, he was unsurprisingly devastated by the change in circumstances, with a major insider revealing how sorry he felt for the 25-year old star. The Ottawa Senators made some big moves at the trade deadline, but none were bigger than giving up franchise mainstay Josh Norris in a deal that saw them acquire Dylan Cozens from the Buffalo Sabres. Since arriving in Ottawa, Cozens had been thriving, showing how happy he is to finally be off the struggling Sabres, but unfortunately on the other side of the coin, Norris was devastated by the move. That comment comes from Elliotte Friedman, who pointed out the obvious as he watched Norris make his debut for the Sabres, as he went from a Stanley Cup Playoffs race to a team that has the longest drought in the NHL, stretching back 14 years. In three games thus far, Norris has tallied a goal and an assist, but given the change in scenery which made Brady Tkachuk immensely emotional after spending six seasons in Ottawa, it's easy to see why he's frustrated and upset about his change in scenery. Ultimately, the Sabres are now likely to keep Norris as a key piece of their future, and with another five years left on his current deal with a $7.95 million cap hit every season. While he's got plenty of talent and could be great for Buffalo, it's hard not to feel sorry for him after all he gave to Ottawa through an injury-riddled run with the team.