New York Giants 2025 NFL Draft Grades

The New York Giants needed to make smart moves in the 2025 NFL Draft to change the direction of the franchise. General Manager Joe Schoen and Head Coach Brian Daboll are trying to save their jobs this year. There was a time when the Giants were recognized as one of the top-tier organizations in the NFL, but they have been a laughingstock in recent seasons. It’s time to grade this year’s draft picks for the New York Giants. 

Round 1, No. 3: Abdul Carter, EDGE, Penn State

Grade: A+

The Giants decided to take the best pass rusher in this draft class. With two veteran quarterbacks already added this offseason, they could afford to wait to draft one. All of their Super Bowls were won with great pass rushers. It looks like the plan is to make the defensive front the strong area of the team. Many experts and people around the league have compared Carter to Micah Parsons of the NFC East rival Dallas Cowboys. The Giants couldn’t pass on that with the 3rd pick. 

Round 1, No. 25: Jaxson Dart, QB, Ole Miss (via Houston Texans)

Grade: B-

I was torn between giving this pick a B- or C+ because they could have waited for round 2. There was concern that the Rams would take Dart so it makes sense why the Giants traded up. Daboll now has his guy, although he will be sitting for his first year, at least to start. Dart has the talent and potential to thrive in the NFL. He has formed a relationship with fellow former Ole Miss and Giants Quarterback Eli Manning, which helps. 

Round 3, No. 65: Darius Alexander, DT, Toledo

Grade: A

New York adds more depth to their already strong defensive line. Alexander has the ability to line up all over the place as he did in college. He is a solid run defender, which will immediately make the Giants better in that area. He had 26 tackles at or behind the line of scrimmage on designed rushes since the start of 2023, the fifth most in FBS. Schoen said that a priority this offseason was to stop the run. 

Round 4, No. 105: Cam Skattebo, RB, Arizona State

Grade: A

This is an absolute steal. Skattebo may very well have an immediate role. He is a strong runner who fights through contact and has tremendous vision. He is also reliable when it comes to catching passes. This is the type of running back the Giants need. 

Round 5, No. 154: Marcus Mbow, G, Purdue (from Seattle Seahawks)

Grade: A

Mbow will most likely go from tackle in college to guard as a pro. Smart pick to add to the offensive line. He has great footwork and is versatile. Some medical concerns possibly contributed to him sliding in the draft. Mbow will have the opportunity to compete for a starting job. 

Round 7, No. 219: Thomas Fidone II, TE, Nebraska

Grade: B+

Fidone is a natural receiver with a bigger body. Although he didn’t meet expectations, there is plenty of potential. He has torn his ACL twice and has a somewhat concerning injury. There is a great opportunity for Fidone to develop as a great player at the next level. 

Round 7, No. 246: Korie Black, CB, Oklahoma State

Grade: B 

The final pick for the Giants in this year’s draft is a cornerback with good ball skills, size, and transition speed. Black adds depth to a thin cornerback depth chart. 

Overall Draft Grade: A

Overall, this was a successful draft for the Giants. Abdul Carter and Travis Hunter were considered the two best all-around players this year. They walked away with Carter, a difference-making pass rusher who can start to contribute on day one.

The Giants have a serious front seven that can do damage, just like their better teams of the past. Dart is now the future franchise quarterback. Skattebo should bring value to the offense in both the run and pass game. We’ll see if the G-Men turn things around after being one of the worst teams in the league.