The Pittsburgh Steelers seem to believe that Aaron Rodgers would give them a better chance to win a Super Bowl next season than Russell Wilson, but one franchise legend clearly has his doubts about that.
Former Steelers head coach Bill Cowher shared some of his thoughts on the team's big quarterback decision during a Tuesday appearance on "The Dan Patrick Show." Cowher said he believes Pittsburgh wanted to re-sign Justin Fields, who has since landed with the New York Jets. Even with Fields out of the picture, Cowher believes the Steelers should stick with familiarity.
Cowher told Patrick that he believes Wilson would be the "best choice" to lead Pittsburgh again in 2025. The former Super Bowl champion does not think Wilson is primarily to blame for the way the Steelers limped to the finish line last season.
"You think about the last five losses, this wasn’t just on Russell Wilson," Cowher said. "Two of the teams you played were in the Super Bowl, and then you lost three games to division teams — two to Baltimore and one to Cincinnati. Those are very much playoff-caliber teams. I think you look at all five and you played against five really good quarterbacks. And the defense did not play up to snuff, to be quite honest with you."
Cowher also questioned how committed Rodgers is to playing.
"You lost Justin, Russell’s still out there. You have a chance to get Aaron Rodgers. Can he still throw it, yes? Is he mobile enough? I think so, but does he really want to play? The longer you wait, you just have to wonder where is his heart and how much does he really want to do it," Cowher added.
"I personally think that Russell Wilson is your best choice."
— Dan Patrick Show (@dpshow) March 18, 2025
– @CowherCBS on who the starting QB should be for the Steelers next season. pic.twitter.com/EHx6CvqSTj
If the Steelers agreed with Cowher, they would already have Wilson back under contract. All indications to this point are that Wilson is Plan B in Pittsburgh.
There have, however, been rumblings that the Steelers are starting to grow frustrated with the Rodgers waiting game.
Wilson, 36, is five years younger than Rodgers. Both quarterbacks are past their primes, but the Steelers know exactly what they are going to get with Wilson. Cowher feels the talent gap between Wilson and Rodgers is not significant enough to justify a major change.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!