Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Titans losing shines light on internal strife
USA TODAY Sports

We are 11 months into Ran Carthon's tenure as general manager of the Tennessee Titans. Neither Carthon nor coach Mike Vrabel envisioned that they would be 4-8 at this point in time, facing a potential nationally-televised ass kicking in Week 14.

Losing wears on an organization, and Tennessee's failures have brought some warts to light.

The Titans roster woes are their greatest source of failure, and no sane person expected Carthon and his staff to flip it in Year 1. The six draft picks made in 2023, all on offense, have contributed right away out of necessity. One of them, quarterback Will Levis, encourages those evaluating him more and more with each start that he makes. 

Losing at this rate, however, has plenty of Tennessee's non-player personnel in survival mode and it is doing an incredible disservice to the talent that is on the roster. 

ESPN's Turron Davenport published a piece this week on the nature of the relationship between Carthon and Vrabel. It comes a few days removed from unverified allegations by Greg Bedard of the Boston Sports Journal about the coach and GM's relationship, owner Amy Adams Strunk's hiring process and even Carthon's work ethic dating back to his time with the San Fransisco 49ers. 

Davenport's article was not meant to be a response to Bedard, but it timed out that way. What was curious was the response that the ESPN article caused.

Multiple sources with the Titans organization pushed back on some of the quotes Carthon provided to ESPN on the team's evaluation process. One section in particular drew the most critical commentary:

Having spent time helping construct the San Francisco 49ers' roster as the director of pro personnel from 2017 to 2020 and then director of player personnel from 2021 to 2022, Carthon saw first-hand how general manager John Lynch and coach Kyle Shanahan worked together with the scouts.

The way the scouts learned exactly what Shanahan wanted resonated with Carthon. He wanted to bring that process to Tennessee so he had coaches produce teaching tape using their terminology to get everyone on the same page.

Multiple team sources questioned the mere existence of these teach tapes with one adding, "If they do, I don't know where they are for us to see them."

It is worth noting that multiple Tennessee assistant coaches are on-record as saying that Carthon and others in the personnel department did put together video assets to show the staff what they were looking for at their respective positions this offseason. That something like that is even being disputed internally speaks to a different level of collaboration than is being portrayed. Carthon and Vrabel may end up working out well together, but the organizational alignment is not currently needs to be.

Sure, the Titans depth chart is littered with disappointment.

Carthon and Vrabel will spend several offseasons trying to put things back together again. Lasting together is something only they can go about figuring out how to accomplish. There is also the factor of individual agendas at play as the finger-pointing goes around. 

Such is life when an organization fires and hires a general manager while employing an incumbent head coach. 

Carthon's decision to keep many of former GM Jon Robinson's hires without extending their contracts puts the staff on notice. It is also far more generous an opportunity than many executives would offer to a group of people that they did not hire. Carthon is as much responsible for evaluating his front office structure as he is current and future Tennessee players.

External optics are one thing. Behind the scenes, there is plenty of work to be done. 

This article first appeared on A to Z Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Pittsburgh Steelers sign two-time Super Bowl champion who looked checked out with AFC North rival in 2024
NFL

Pittsburgh Steelers sign two-time Super Bowl champion who looked checked out with AFC North rival in 2024

The Pittsburgh Steelers aren't afraid of signing or drafting characters. Especially when those characters have a Super Bowl resume and or championship pedigree. And that's exactly what they just did with their latest move... Steelers sign safety Juan Thornhill to one year deal Cleveland had high hopes for Juan Thornhill when they signed him to a three-year deal after moving on from John Johnson III. Thornhill played two years of that contract out and the Browns moved on from him before free agency started. The former Kansas City Chiefs' biggest issue in Cleveland was his ability to stay healthy. In back-to-back seasons, Thornhill missed six games for the Browns. When on the field, Thornhill’s play was inconsistent at best. The losing ways of the Browns did not help his case at all, as he appeared to be checked out at times. In 2024, Thornhill played his best ball toward the end of the season when he was a bit healthier. The veteran safety isn’t going to be a name that you call home about, but he is a player who will stick his nose in on any tackle. Thornhill isn’t a ball-hawking safety but is a capable contributor when he is on the field. He has the winning experience from Kansas City and knows what it takes for a team to have a winning locker room. A vocal player that fans will love/hate depending on how he is doing on the field. - Brandon Little, A to Z Sports Cleveland Look, a lot of Steelers fans are going to say "I'd jog to if I played for the Browns" or take shots at Cleveland, but that kind of effort is never acceptable. It reminisces what we saw from key figures on the Steeler's defense against the Baltimore Ravens in the playoffs. So maybe Thornhill is right at home. In all seriousness, it's a solid depth piece for Pittsburgh. The starters at safety are obviously DeShon Elliott and Minkah Fitzpatrick, but Pittsburgh plays a lot of three-safety looks in their big nickel package and they have yet to re-sign Damontae Kazee, with Thornhill all but taking his spot. Sometimes a fresh start is all a player needs, and having yet to turn 30 with over six years worth of starting experience, a low-cost rental for someone with Thornhill's tape isn't a bad deal.

Extending Connor Bedard could be a challenge for Blackhawks
NHL

Extending Connor Bedard could be a challenge for Blackhawks

When the Chicago Blackhawks drafted Connor Bedard in the 2023 NHL Entry Draft, the organization expected the team to be better in the coming years. In 2025, the team has made little gain and is still a bottom-feeder in the NHL. While it is unlikely that Bedard would leave Chicago so soon, there is still the possibility that he may consider signing elsewhere. Blackhawks have been unsuccessful in adding talent Outside of their drafting, the organization has been struggling to sign or trade for top-end talent. Whether it be on offense or defense, GM Kyle Davidson hasn’t really attempted to add a right-hand man for Bedard. Since Bedard’s arrival in Chicago, the biggest addition the team received was Spencer Knight. Even though Knight is a promising young goaltender, his addition would only help Bedard’s defensive reliance. If the Blackhawks want to make the most out of Bedard, adding a superstar forward is the better option. There is arguably no forward that can come close to Bedard’s skill on the Blackhawks. Davidson has surrounded Bedard with some star players like Tyler Bertuzzi and Teuvo Teravainen, but they just can’t keep up with Bedard. Bedard is an extremely fast forward who has to slow down to maintain speeds with the two 30-year-olds. If he were given someone faster, like Maple Leafs’ superstar Mitch Marner, Bedard would be able to play to his full potential. Bedard may struggle with continued losing Nobody likes losing, but a lot of the time, players are forced to ignore post-loss frustrations. The Blackhawks are 31st in the league with a 20-37-9 record for 49 points in 66 games. Despite Bedard giving his all, the team still struggles to give theirs. Bedard is forced to play his own game and, as a result, hasn’t been able to produce to his full potential. The former first-rounder has 52 points in 66 games, consisting of 17 goals and 35 assists. Bedard has been getting frustrated with how things have been going in Chicago. The 19-year-old received a 10-minute game misconduct penalty and was clearly frustrated. Even though this had nothing to do with the Blackhawks, added tensions on the ice can lead into the locker room and cause a rift between the forward and the team.

Fraser Minten's outstanding performance sparks major regret over Leafs' deadline trade with Bruins
NHL

Fraser Minten's outstanding performance sparks major regret over Leafs' deadline trade with Bruins

The Toronto Maple Leafs included prospect Fraser Minten in the deal with the Bruins in exchange for Brandon Carlo, a move they may now be regretting. The Maple Leafs felt that they needed to beef up their blue line for the stretch run leading up to the 2025 Stanley Cup playoffs, and they pulled off a rare trade with their Original 6 and Atlantic Division foe Boston Bruins. The Leafs acquired defenseman Brandon Carlo from the Bruins and in return sent prospect Fraser Minten along with a first-round pick in the 2026 NHL Entry Draft and a fourth-round pick in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft to Boston. While it wasn't the easiest of decisions for general manager Brad Treliving to move a highly regarded prospect to a divisional foe, he hopes it pays off in the long run (and more immediately with postseason success in this especially pivotal year for his club). Fraser Minten Already Making Waves In Boston However, Minten is making the Leafs consider if moving him was the best option. He's already lighting it up with the AHL's Providence Bruins, having picked up a natural hat trick in Sunday's game against the Springfield Falcons. The Leafs made Minten the 38th overall pick in the 2022 NHL Entry Draft, and he's played the bulk of his professional career in the minors with the WHL's Kamloops Blazers along with the AHL's Toronto Marlies. He has 19 total NHL games under his belt with four points (2G, 2A). He scored his first NHL goal earlier this season only seconds into his first shift, which was a hopeful sign of things to come for the future of Minten with the team, but it was short-lived. Before being traded to the Bruins, Minten had 13 points (6G, 7A) in 26 games with the Marlies. He struggled over his past dozen or so games, but with his latest outburst of production, it's safe to say he's finding his offensive game. Which is a hard pill to swallow if you're a Maple Leafs fan.

It Is Finally Known What Injury Vancouver Canucks Goaltender Thatcher Demko is Dealing With
NHL

It Is Finally Known What Injury Vancouver Canucks Goaltender Thatcher Demko is Dealing With

Thatcher Demko hasn't suited up for the Vancouver Canucks in over a month and we now know what type of injury the netminder is dealing with. In early February, the Vancouver Canucks were taking on the Toronto Maple Leafs for their final game before the 4 Nations Face-Off and unfortunately Thatcher Demko suffered an injury halfway through the first period. A few days after the 4 Nations Face-Off wrapped up, the Canucks made the decision to place Demko on injured reserve with what they called a lower-body injury. Injury to Vancouver Canucks goaltender Thatcher Demko revealed During an appearance on Halford and Brough on Sportsnet 650 radio on Friday, Rick Dhaliwal shared that Thatcher Demko is dealing with a groin injury, something he knows quite about from the 2022-23 season which caused the netminder to miss close to three months. Dhaliwal added that it's been tough for Thatcher Demko to get into practices with how the Canucks' schedule has played out including two sets of back-to-backs this week - Tuesday/Wednesday and Saturday/Sunday. 'The Canucks schedule is not helping. Demko needs full team practices before he plays games. When you have back-to-backs, you've got to take the third day off, so there's not much time for practices.' Dhaliwal said on Halford and Brough. The Canucks did get some good news on Friday when they hit the ice at UBC for practice as Thatcher Demko participated for about 20 minutes before departing to the locker room, which was the plan. 'per team plan, Thatcher Demko's first #Canucks practice in 5 weeks comes to a prescribed early ending. Skated with group for about 35 minutes. Was actively involved. Expected to ramp things up in days ahead.' Jeff Paterson of Rink Wide: Vancouver said. Demko, 28, has had a rough 12 months on the injury front which includes two knee ailments which delayed his 2024-25 season debut until early December against the St. Louis Blues. In 17 games this season, Demko has a 6-6-3 record along with a 2.87 goals against average, an .891 save percentage and one shutout. Source: Rick Dhaliwal/Halford and Brough Dhali With A Canucks Update + What We Learned