The Stanley Cup playoffs field is set, and it's time to look at the next crop of potential playoff heroes.
Seemingly no tournament in sports offers as much opportunity for an unlikely hero to shine as the NHL's postseason. Of course, big names often earn playoffs MVP — 27 of 39 Conn Smythe Trophy winners are enshrined in the Hockey Hall of Fame.
But Justin Williams, winner of the award in 2014 while with the Stanley-Cup-winning Los Angeles Kings, was hardly a household name. The longtime winger had a few truly excellent seasons, but he was mostly a middle-of-the-lineup type who seemed to shine in the biggest moments.
In this year's field is there a Justin Williams, another under-the-radar player who will excel and whose team will make a deep playoff run? Here are five potential candidates:
Winger Brandon Hagel, Tampa Bay Lightning | First round vs. Florida
Most players on this list are either entering the playoffs hot, amid a career season or have a history of playoff success. Hagel fits all three of these categories.
Once upon a time the Lightning were (briefly) lampooned for how much they gave up to acquire him in a trade with Chicago. Hagel has a career-high 90 points and 35 goals this season and 22 points in his past 20 games.
In Hagel's past two trips to the playoffs, he has 10 points in 11 games. He does most of his damage at 5-on-5.
Brandon Hagel rewriting the history books. ✍️ pic.twitter.com/ONLiV4bFj9
— BarDown (@BarDown) April 16, 2025
Defenseman Josh Morrissey, Winnipeg Jets | First round vs. St. Louis
The simple case for Morrissey is that he's a minutes-munching defenseman (first on Winnipeg in time-on-ice) who plays more than any other skater, will face the toughest matchups and also can put up points.
Historically, Morrissey is not a big playoff scorer. But he is coming off his third consecutive 60-point regular season and scored four points in five playoff games last season. If there ever was a time for Morrissey to put it all together, it's now.
Center Quinton Byfield, Los Angeles Kings | First round vs. Edmonton
He's been a highlight machine for months now following a terribly slow start to the season. At 6-foot-5, 225 pounds and with the type of speed, agility and hand-eye coordination that can change a game, it's possible we are seeing Byfield turn into the next Rick Nash, whose playoff success was hit-or-miss. But in the modern era, Byfield fits the exact mold of a player who could excel in the tight-checking playoffs. He has 34 points in 39 games (14 goals, 20 assists) during the back half of the season.
How… how did Quinton Byfield do this… pic.twitter.com/H5oTPrv24V
— Zach Cavanagh (@ZachCav) April 8, 2025
Center Roope Hintz, Dallas Stars | First round vs. Colorado
For the Stars to come out of a crowded Western Conference, someone must be a matchup problem for opponents. Hintz, a three-time 30-goal scorer, has a killer instinct and could be that guy. He torched opponents in the 2022-23 playoffs with 24 points in 19 games in the first of his two consecutive trips to the Western Conference Final.
Goaltender Jordan Binnington, St. Louis Blues | First round vs. Winnipeg
Binnington flirted with earning a Conn Smyth during St. Louis' 2019 championship run — the games that launched his career. Mix in his gold-medal performance at the 4 Nations Face-Off in February and the Blues being the hottest team in hockey with wins in 20 of 29 games, and it's easy to see Binnington's case despite a middling statistical season. But his numbers for his past 10 games are impressive (8-1-1 record, .917 save percentage and only 21 goals allowed).
The Stanley Cup playoffs will begin Saturday (April 19).
UNREAL SAVE FROM BINNINGTON #4Nations OVERTIME on ESPN, ESPN+, Disney+ pic.twitter.com/8M5810qs4d
— ESPN (@espn) February 21, 2025
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!