Maple Leafs Playing Ryan Reaves Is a Calculated Risk

The Toronto Maple Leafs’ Ryan Reaves has returned for a reason for tonight’s series opener with the young Ottawa Senators. When you hear terms like “bloodbath” tossed around or see two teams gearing up for a physical showdown, it’s no surprise that Reaves is back in the mix. The playoffs demand a particular brand of toughness, and Reaves delivers it with every shift. His role? Set the tone, hit everything in sight, and make sure the Maple Leafs aren’t outmuscled.

But there’s a balancing act here. Playoff hockey rewards physical intensity—but only the kind that comes with control. Refs are quick to call retaliation, and for sure, they want to control the game. Nobody in Toronto wants a repeat of a Nazem Kadri-type situation against the Boston Bruins, how many seasons ago? One reckless moment can undo the impact of a dozen clean hits.

The Risk-Reward Game of Physical Play During the Postseason

Deploying a player like Reaves is a calculated risk. While his energy and physical presence can spark the Maple Leafs, it also has the potential to escalate the entire game. That might work in Toronto’s favor—or not. The concern isn’t whether Reaves can hold his own, but whether a rising physical temperature leads to a cheap shot on someone like Matthews or Marner. And in a long playoff series, that’s the trade-off that can keep a coach up at night.

Expect the Senators’ Strategy to Pressure the Maple Leafs’ Core

There’s no doubt about Ottawa’s game plan: make life miserable for Toronto’s stars. That means heavy forechecks, tight gaps, and taking every opportunity to deliver a hit. The idea is simple—make the Maple Leafs hesitant to carry the puck, force rushed decisions, and create turnovers. It’s a formula that’s worked against Toronto in the past.

But this isn’t the same Maple Leafs team. It’s tougher, stronger, and more able to push back.

Berube’s Influence and the Maple Leafs’ Response

Craig Berube knows this kind of hockey better than most. He’s built for it—and he builds teams for it. Under his watch, the Maple Leafs aren’t just skill-heavy; they’re mentally and physically tougher. While the Senators might come in looking to impose their will, they’ll find a team far more capable of answering the bell.

Gone are the days of the Maple Leafs getting steamrolled in physical series, like the one against the Bruins several years ago. This version of Toronto doesn’t just take hits—they give them back. Matthews might still smile through the scrums, but around him are players more than willing to engage.