As a small-town resident growing up in the Pacific Northwest, visiting Madison Square Garden (MSG) for any reason was not on my bingo card. It was completely out of the realm of possibility, frankly. But life comes at you fast, and New York City comes faster.
Despite being an older millennial whose idea of going out is going to the Starbucks down the street in slow-paced Northern New Jersey, who could turn down an NHL game? Read about the New York Rangers and the Toronto Maple Leafs facing off on February 28th, as well as this NYC newbie’s take on the game below!
Long-time listeners of the Tailgate Update, or readers who caught my article reminiscing about 1990s hockey, know I harp on the NHL of yesteryear. When the entire hockey team would be crammed inside the penalty box after a huge fight, goalie padding was bigger than the player wearing them, and blood flowed and teeth flew nearly every game. It’s hard to reconcile with 2025 hockey.
It’s been almost 20 years since I have watched a full NHL game, although my heart has always been with the Toronto Maple Leafs. I picked them as my team when I was 4, and I’ll never look back. Seeing an in-person game felt like a far-distant dream in the height of my hockey appreciation. Who wouldn’t take the opportunity to see their team in person, playing against the New York Rangers? Particularly in the MSG.
Beware: If you aren’t ready for it, you might have your breath taken away the first time you behold the venues of all venues. Madison Square Garden is a cultural icon on its own, holding so many sports and cultural moments within its elegant walls for decades. If you get a chance to attend an event in the MSG, you have to do it!
Being in the MSG is the absolutely best way to start any sporting event. We were in the second section, giving us a fantastic view of the entire rink. I had great company (shout out to Bill and Greg!) and as much Miller Lite as a girl could want. One benefit of being a woman at a sporting event is that finally it’s your turn to have extremely short bathroom lines. Am I right, ladies?
I was a little on edge after the ‘excitement’ at the 4 Nations United States-Canada game a week prior. That was important because the anthems were painful. A lovely gentleman first sang the Canadian anthem with an alarming number of boos echoing through the venue. The fervor with which people cheered while the man was during the United States anthem was equally disconcerting.
Besides that, there was an individual who got after me about needing to scoot past them to leave my row. I had much stronger words for her during last week’s Tailgate Update episode. I’ll say here that maybe she was so unnecessarily mean because she kept yelling for the manager of a beer stand and couldn’t find one.
Not my problem, not my business. The zen sound of skates gliding through ice, with sticks hitting pucks, and players checking each other into boards is both quiet and relaxing. It’s hard to stay mad that way.
Unsurprisingly, I haven’t been keeping up with the NHL or the Toronto Maple Leafs season super closely this year. It was reassuring to see how clean, efficient, and competent they looked out there on the ice. Especially their goalie, Anthony Stolarz, who shined. The same could not be said for the Rangers. They did decide to show up in the second period, but they still had to work harder to do less than Toronto every step of the way. See the second-period summary below for context.
The Leafs started out the game hot with a point by veteran OEL within the first two minutes of the game. It took the Rangers 12 more minutes of gameplay to get their first, incredibly impressive goal from God’s ear to Mika Zibanejad’s stick.
Toronto snuck a close one in at the beginning of the second period. It was under review for a long period of time since the whistle had been blown before the goal was made. William Nylander got the puck in the goal crease, and the New York Rangers finished business with one player attempting to knock the puck out, and the goalie scoring against himself, escorting the puck in with his glove. Eventually, it was deemed a goal.
Things got cooking in the third period. Will Cuylle tied the game with a beautiful goal he snuck into the corner of the net. He ended up slamming the goal post after scoring and nearly checked it into the wall. However, the Maple Leafs got the last laugh when Matthew Knies squeaked their final goal past Ranger’s goalie Jonny Brodzinski with 13:39 left on the clock.
There’s not much to speak of here. I counted eight overall penalties and two tiny disagreements that could have been charitably referred to as fights. There was a little tripping, interference, holding, icing, a tiny push, and cross-checking. I had never seen a ‘too many men’ call during a game, so that felt remarkable when the New York Rangers couldn’t count in the second period. The most rousing penalty would be the rather vicious high-sticking to the head in the last two minutes of the third period. They gave the crowd a little something.
If you ever get a chance to go to the Big Apple and attend any event at the MSG, you have to do it! If it’s an NHL game, it’s a must. The New York Rangers are inconsistent, so you don’t know what you will get—they won the next two games on March 1st and 2nd with shutouts. The Maple Leafs made me proud with their 3-2 score. Overall, the experience was fantastic, and hopefully I have motivated you to attend an NHL game, no matter where you are. Catch more of my articles here!
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!