-
Follow Us
On Facebook
On Flipboard
On Twitter
The San Diego Padres haven’t been around for as long as some of the other franchises in Major League Baseball, but some of the greatest players in the league’s history have played for their team.
They may not have led the Padres to any World Series titles, and while they seem to be in a great spot to contend for a championship currently, that doesn’t mean they haven’t had good players on their roster. So with the Padres in a current stretch of success, let’s take a trip down memory lane and look at some of the best players from their franchise’s history.
10. Randy Jones
Position: Starting Pitcher
Years with Padres: 1973-1980
Notable Accolades: 1976 NL CY Young, Two-time All-Star
If it weren’t for a dominant two season stretch in 1975 and 1976, Randy Jones almost certainly wouldn’t have made this list. But Jones was so dominant during those two seasons that he managed to land a spot here.
After leading the league in losses in 1974 with 22, Jones managed to put together a near Cy Young campaign the next season (20-12, 2.24 ERA, 103 K, 1.05 WHIP) from out of nowhere. He did manage to win the Cy Young in 1976 (22-14, 2.74 ERA, 93 K, 1.03 WHIP) after leading the league in starts (40) and complete game (25).
Jones was never able to replicate this two-season stretch and was okay throughout the rest of his career, but for a point in time, he was arguably the best pitcher in the league.
9. Andy Benes
Position: Starting Pitcher
Years with Padres: 1989-1995
Notable Accolades: 1993 NL All-Star
Andy Benes is another example of how consistency can help you make your mark with the Padres. He was never the best pitcher ever, but he always managed to find a way to go out and give his team a chance to win, and that was what made him special.
Benes was an innings-eater early on in his career with San Diego, and he managed to earn some Cy Young consideration in 1991 with a strong campaign. He was an All-Star in 1993 (15-15, 3.78 ERA, 179 K, 1.24 WHIP) even if it wasn’t necessarily his strongest season.
Benes led the NL in strikeouts in 1994, as well as losses with 14 strangely enough, but he struggled in 1995 and ended up being traded to the Seattle Mariners. Still, Benes was a consistent pitcher for the Padres, earning himself a place in their history.
8. Adrian Gonzalez
Position: First Base
Years with Padres: 2006-2010
Notable Accolades: Three-time NL All-Star, Two-time Gold Glove winner
Adrian Gonzalez seemed to be on the brink of superstardom when he was traded to the Boston Red Sox, but with his career now over, it’s clear that Gonzalez’s best stretch of baseball came during his time with the Padres. Gonzalez found his way into the starting lineup in 2006, and quickly established himself as one of the top first basemen in MLB.
Gonzalez did it all with San Diego, as he hit for a high average and around 30 home runs, drove in tons of runs, and played great defense at first base. Gonzalez’s best season with the Padres was his last one in 2010 (.298 BA, 31 HR, 101 RBI, .904 OPS), which saw him finish fourth in the NL MVP race.
It didn’t seem like it at the time, but that ended up being Gonzalez’s peak, and he will always be remembered as one of the greatest Padres of all time.
7. Fernando Tatis, Jr.
Positions: Right Field and Shortstop
Years with Padres: 2019-2025
Notable Accolades: Two-time All-Star, 2022 NL HR champ, 2023 NL Platinum Glove
Since he burst on the scene as a 20-year-old rookie, Fernando Tatis, Jr., has shown tremendous talent. However, the son of a former major-leaguer has battled injuries and was even suspended for half a season for testing positive for a banned substance. Tatis has even missed a full season in 2022.
Originally a shortstop, Tatis transitioned to right field in 2023, and he took to it right away. In fact, he won the Platinum Glove in 2023 for being the NL’s overall best defender. Tatis also led the NL in home runs with 42 in 2021.
However, Tatis’ biggest impact has been in the playoffs. The Padres have made the postseason twice with Tatis, in 2020 and 2024. In just 13 career playoff games, Tatis has an astounding 1.328 OPS with six home runs and 12 RBIs. The scary part is, Tatis has yet to reach his peak years.
6. Andy Ashby
Position: Starting Pitcher
Years with Padres: 1993-1999, 2004
Notable Accolades: Two-time NL All-Star
Andy Ashby stuck around with the Padres for longer than most folks behind him on this list, and his strong play throughout his tenure has helped him crack a spot on this list. Ashby was never the greatest pitcher, but he consistently ate innings, and he really found his stride towards the end of his tenure with San Diego.
Ashby was an All-Star in 1998 and 1999, his two final seasons with the Padres, but that was about as high as his career went. He returned in 2004 but only pitched in two games for two innings, but by then, his status with San Diego was already set in stone.
Even if they aren’t the most glamorous numbers, Ashby held their rotation together for much of the 90s, and is an easy choice for this greatest Padres of all time list.
5. Manny Machado
Position: Third Base
Years with Padres: 2019-2025
Notable Accolades: Two-time NL All-Star, Two-time Silver Slugger
Manny Machado went from pariah to fan favorite in San Diego when he left the hated division-rival Los Angeles Dodgers to sign a 10-year, $300 million contract with the Padres, which was the biggest contract in American sports history at the time. Machado became the team leader for a resurgent franchise that hadn’t made the playoffs in more than a decade.
Since Machado’s arrival, the Padres have reached the playoffs three times and got as far as the NL Championship Series in 2022. Machado twice finished Top 3 in NL MVP voting and has already become the Padres’ all-time leading home run hitter. He’s also fourth in Padres history in RBIs and runs scored, third in total bases, and seventh in hits.
4. Trevor Hoffman
Position: Closer
Years with Padres: 1993-2008
Notable Accolades: Six-time NL All-Star, Two-time Rolaids Relief winner, Hall of Famer
A seemingly harmless trade with the Florida Marlins that involved Trevor Hoffman ended up giving the Padres one of the best closers in the history of the MLB. Hoffman took over as the team’s full time closer in 1994 and never looked back. Hoffman was about as consistent as they come, and the fact that he very nearly won the Cy Young twice as a closer shows how good he was.
Hoffman’s superstar season in 1998 (4-2, 1.48 ERA, 53 SV, 86 K, 0.85 WHIP) saw him finish second in the Cy Young race, and he finished second again in 2006, his age 38 season, with another fantastic campaign (0-2, 2.14 ERA, 46 SV, 50 K, 0.97 WHIP).
Hoffman’s 601 total saves are second in MLB history, and it’s no surprise that he found his way into the Hall of Fame. Safe to say, Hoffman won’t be forgotten.
3. Jake Peavy
Position: Starting Pitcher
Years with Padres: 2002-2009
Notable Accolades: 2007 NL CY Young, 2007 Triple Crown winner, Two-time NL All-Star
It wasn’t the longest stretch, but Jake Peavy was absolutely electric early on in his career with the Padres. It took a while for him to find his way, but Peavy announced himself to the world in 2004 when he led the majors with a 2.27 ERA.
Peavy was an All-Star in 2005 before struggling in 2006, paving the way for a historic 2007 campaign that saw him win the pitching triple crown and the NL Cy Young award (19-6, 2.54 ERA, 240 K, 1.06 WHIP).
Peavy eventually found his way off the lowly Padres, but he was never as good as he was to start his career with San Diego, and his 2007 season will continue to be regarded as one of the greatest recent seasons of pitching for quite some time.
2. Dave Winfield
Position: Right Field
Years with Padres: 1973-1980
Notable Accolades: Four-time NL All-Star, Two-time Gold Glove winner, Hall of Famer
Dave Winfield will likely be remembered more for his contributions with the New York Yankees, but before he became a full-fledged star with them, he got his start with the Padres. Winfield gradually turned himself into an indispensable piece of San Diego’s lineup, hitting for contact and power while playing great defense in right field as well.
Winfield was an All-Star in his final four seasons with San Diego, but his best season was easily in 1979 (.308 BA, 34 HR, 118 RBIs, 15 SB, .953 OPS) when he finished third in the NL MVP voting. He remained productive well into his 40s, but without his start with the Padres, none of his later success would have happened, and Winfield is easily one of their best players of all time.
1. Tony Gwynn
Position: Right Field
Years with Padres: 1982-2001
Notable Accolades: 15-time NL All-Star, Five-time Gold Glove winner, Eight-time NL Batting Champ, Seven-time Silver Slugger, Hall of Famer
There were some close calls earlier in this list, but this isn’t even close. Tony Gwynn, also known as Mr. Padre, is far and away the greatest player in the franchise’s history, and it isn’t particularly close. One of the best pure contact hitters in the game, Gwynn hit above .300 in every season but his rookie campaign in 1982, in which he only played in 54 games.
Gwynn never won an MVP, but he was an absolute machine at the plate. He won eight batting titles, and he very nearly hit for .400 in 1994, finishing with a .394 average, which is just absurd.
Gwynn played elite defense in right field as well, and his legacy with the team is untouchable. It will be a long time until anyone finds a way to top Gwynn on this list, and there’s a good chance that it may never end up happening.
More must-reads:
- Yankees place starter on IL following abysmal outing
- Pirates call up former No. 1 overall pick
- The 'MLB yearly hits leaders since 2000' quiz
Breaking News
Customize Your Newsletter
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
PRIVACY POLICY EDITORIAL POLICY CONTACT US
ABOUT YARDBARKER TERMS OF SERVICE
Use of this website (including any and all parts and
components) constitutes your acceptance of these
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
This site is for entertainment purposes only.
There is no gambling offered on this site.
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler.
